Skip to the contentRena
  1. Forum
  2. Passive
  3. Private REITs (Investor)
LossPrivate REITs (Investor)

Six years in, the sponsor called a special dividend and I lost the reinvestment timing entirely

I went in on a diversified non-traded REIT in late 2018, $150K, stated NAV held around $10.30 for the first three years and distributions came through reliably at 5.6%. That part matched what I was told. Then in Q3 2022 the sponsor declared a special dividend, $0.47 per share, which sounds fine until you realize it pulled forward income I had been deferring and triggered a taxable event I had no room for that year. My accountant figured the after-tax drag on that single distribution at roughly 90 basis points annualized when you spread it across my remaining hold. I also had a 1031 deadline that month and the cash from the special dividend hit my account with about nine days notice, which was useless for exchange purposes and just sat there getting taxed. The NAV came down 4.1% in the next two quarterly appraisals, not dramatically, just enough that when I finally got a partial redemption approved in early 2024 at the then-current NAV of $9.81, the six-year total return net of fees and taxes was somewhere around 18%, which is barely 2.8% annualized and does not account for what I would have done with that $150K in 2018 if I had not needed something I thought was simpler than it turned out to be. The illiquidity I understood. The unilateral distribution timing I did not.

1 reply

The nine days notice on that special dividend is the part that should have been in the PPM in plain language and almost never is. I had a similar situation with a non-traded REIT I went into in 2019, smaller position, and the sponsor language around distribution timing was buried in a section titled "Tax Matters" that was basically written to protect them, not inform me. My net annualized on that one came out closer to 3.4% over five years, which is bad but yours at 2.8% is worse when you factor in where short-term rates went after mid-2022. The NAV methodology is the other thing nobody argues about until the appraisal cycle lags reality, and a 4.1% drop over two quarters on a diversified vehicle usually means the underlying was moving before the appraiser caught it. Redemption queues in 2023 and 2024 were running six to nine months for partial approvals on most of the mid-size platforms I was watching, so getting out in early 2024 even at $9.81 was not nothing.