Story
Bought into a non-traded REIT in 2019, parked about $80k there, thought nothing of it. Then in 2022 I was mid-application on a cash-out refi on my Cleveland fourplex and the lende…
Discussion
He was reviewing a private REIT subscription for a client of his and he called me because he knows I have looked at a few of these. He said the operating agreement had a clause th…
Discussion
I am in a non-traded REIT that holds a mix of suburban office and light industrial, 14 properties, NAV stated at $10.44 as of last quarter. I pulled the most recent annual report…
Happening Now
Spent two hours on this today. The sponsor looks fine on paper, March 2023 offering, $50M raise target, office/industrial mix in the Carolinas. Audited financials, yes, but I went…
Happening Now
An advisor's line worth sitting with: if you are buying a private REIT, you are buying a story. Take an investor who owns a few residential units in Wrocław outright, no debt, and…
Discussion
I hear that constantly and I used to half-believe it myself. But nine doors in, all rehabbed, I am the hassle. My whole model is active. I'm the one pulling permits and arguing wi…
Loss
I went in on a diversified non-traded REIT in late 2018, $150K, stated NAV held around $10.30 for the first three years and distributions came through reliably at 5.6%. That part…
Happening Now
Take a $340k position in a non-traded REIT, 22 months in, paying 5.8 percent on a stated NAV of $10.12. The repurchase window opens in q3 and is capped at 5 percent of NAV, so the…
Discussion
There is a line some accountants use on LP clients, that what they really own is the paperwork rather than the real estate. It is meant as a criticism, and it is hard to disagree…
Discussion
Consider a private REIT posting NAV updates quarterly that drifts down 2.1 percent over six quarters, no single bad quarter, just a slow grind. The sponsor calls it normal apprais…
Poll
Been reading about non-traded REITs after a conversation on a job site and I don't understand the core sell. The pitch is that shares don't swing with daily market sentiment, so y…
Loss
I've been researching for months and hadn't bought anything, so when an advisor walked me through a public non-traded REIT I was ready to move. Minimum was 2,500, I put in 20,000.…
Win
I had 120k to place and no interest in watching a ticker. The thing I wanted to know before committing was whether the sponsor's repurchase plan had ever been tested and what happ…
Discussion
I'm sorting through which parts of this industry I might actually want to be in, and non-traded REITs keep coming up as the passive option. What I don't understand is what I'm act…
Happening Now
Take an investor sitting on land sale proceeds, say roughly 240k net after costs, who is not replacing the parcel this cycle because entitlement timelines in the county have gotte…
Loss
This is a case worth walking through in full because the numbers make the lesson concrete. Take an investor with 60k into a private non-traded REIT, a Reg D offering through an ac…
Poll
Anyone funding a first small position in a public non-traded REIT hits the same fork on the subscription form: take distributions in cash to a bank account, or reinvest them into…
Discussion
Working through the valuation section of a public non-traded REIT raises a fair question about how much weight the NAV can carry. Monthly NAV, an independent valuation advisor rev…
Happening Now
Here is a comparison sheet worth breaking. Non traded NAV REIT, quoted distribution rate 5.5 percent on NAV, sponsor's own materials suggesting low single digit NAV appreciation o…
Poll
Two public non-traded REITs quoting distribution rates within a quarter point of each other can be running very different machines underneath. One at 34% loan to value, mostly fix…
Poll
Two things came across my desk in the same month. One is a public non-traded REIT holding nothing but data centers and a small amount of build-to-suit development. The other is a…
Poll
Income-focused investors often land on public non-traded REITs, the registered kind with audited financials and a $2,500 minimum, and the harder question is always position size r…
Loss
An investor running several renovation projects at once typically carries a cash reserve for overruns. Parking that reserve, say $85,000, in a business savings account earning lit…
Happening Now
I have 18k sitting from a settlement and the first rental doesn't close for another five months, so I've been reading about public non-traded REITs as a place to put part of it in…
Discussion
Working through a public non-traded REIT prospectus, the share class mechanics on Class T don't reconcile cleanly at first read. Class T typically carries a 3.0 percent upfront se…
Discussion
Everything is new here so forgive the level of this. I looked at two of these. One said $2,500 minimum and asked nothing about my income. The other had a form asking me to certify…
Happening Now
Framing job last week, one of the guys says he put 30k into a private REIT through some platform and he can't get it out for two years. He said it like it was a good thing. I've b…
Loss
Consider an investor who bought into a public non-traded REIT in 2018 through an advisor, 60k, Class A shares, diversified, heavy on suburban office and grocery-anchored retail wi…
Happening Now
Consider an investor holding a position in a public non-traded REIT for several years. The sponsor files a change in the independent valuation advisor engaged to review the monthl…
Poll
Registered non-traded REITs with a modest minimum, say around 2,500 dollars, are often the first entry point into this category for investors used to lower price points. There are…
Win
I put 12k into a public non-traded REIT last year. This is the smallest amount I've ever felt nervous about, and the reason I'm writing it up is that the part that mattered wasn't…
Happening Now
The advisory agreement and repurchase plan behind a NAV REIT usually reward closer reading than the fact sheet invites. A typical performance participation runs 12.5% of total ret…
Discussion
The fee side deserves the numbers before anything else. Say an investor puts in $50,000. What comes off the top before a dollar reaches a building, and what comes off every year a…
Discussion
The offering doc for a public non-traded REIT I'm reading caps share repurchases at 5% of NAV per quarter, with the board able to suspend the program entirely. Say the fund holds…
Happening Now
Sitting on 78k in cash. About 55k of it is the down payment plus reserves for a small rental I expect to close on in roughly nine months, assuming the market I'm shopping cooperat…
Win
For an investor whose income already moves with the market, the appeal of a non-traded REIT structure is often less about return and more about not watching a ticker swing on unre…
Discussion
A common sticking point before anyone funds a public non-traded REIT is the tax paperwork. Investors who do private real estate deals will often say anything like this sends a K-1…
Happening Now
Numbers first, as always in this kind of decision. Take a six unit building, older brick, in a market well understood by its owner. Gross scheduled rent 78k, actual collections la…
Poll
Two offering documents in front of me. One is a public non-traded REIT: registered with the SEC, audited annual financials, quarterly filings, $2,500 minimum, monthly subscription…
Discussion
Take an investor with a small rental portfolio looking at a non-traded REIT for the part of the money that should not be tied to a roof. The offering says distributions may be fun…
Happening Now
A public non-traded REIT with roughly 62% of trailing year distributions funded from cash flow from operations, with the remainder coming from offering proceeds and a fee waiver b…
Poll
Been reading offering documents for a few months now and I can't settle this one, so I'll put it to the room. The pitch for non-traded REITs is that the shares don't swing with da…
Win
Take an investor with 85k sitting from a lump sum, most of it earmarked for a public non-traded NAV REIT. The exit is usually the part that's hardest to get comfortable with, so a…