Loss
I put in $5,000 last October, which is not life-changing money but it is my first intentional real estate investment as opposed to the two things I inherited. The deal is a wareho…
Happening Now
A deal I have been turning over lately involves a preferred equity position that converts to common interest if the sponsor misses two consecutive preferred distributions. The str…
Win
Advertised was 14 to 16. I went in knowing that was a projection, so I'm not upset, but 11.2 against my 65 percent LTV entry on the deal still beats what a comparable note would h…
Happening Now
Been staring at this since I signed the purchase agreement. On the duplex I budgeted about $180 a month into reserves, which is roughly 4 percent of what the two units should brin…
Story
A deal worth studying: a 48-unit garden-style project in a secondary market, senior balance at 3.1 million, a crowdfunded mezzanine position behind it at 680k, and a sponsor who s…
Discussion
Looking at a deal right now where the distribution schedule says quarterly but the obligation language says "when cash flow permits." Those are different things and the gap betwee…
Happening Now
Put $30,000 into a multifamily value-add in Columbus, Ohio, 36-month term, 8% pref, 70/30 split above it. I did the math going in on compound and had a number in my head around $3…
Win
Here is a case worth studying. Take an investor who enters one platform position in 2019 and sits on it for five years while everyone around them stacks new deals every quarter. T…
Discussion
Conventional wisdom in my circle was that any retail component in a residential deal drags the whole thing down, too much vacancy risk, too much TI exposure, and lenders who price…
Discussion
That's dead money, and it happened on the last three maturities too. I'm running about 90 days a year where my crowdfunding capital is just sitting in a queue. Does anyone actuall…
Poll
Entitlement and land banking plays on crowdfunding portals tend to sit behind an accreditation wall, while the open offerings on the same portals are usually pooled vehicles holdi…
Discussion
Deal page lists the sponsor as "$400M+ transacted, 40+ projects" and that's it. Nothing about how many of those went full cycle, no realized returns, no mention of the ones that d…
Happening Now
Value-add multifamily on a portal, 96 units, 1978 construction, three story walk-ups, two markets over from where I do my renovation work. $28.5M purchase, $1.77M renovation budge…
Win
The deal was a 68,000 square foot storage facility in a secondary southeast market with a 22,000 foot climate controlled addition to be built on excess pad. Portal deal, accredite…
Discussion
This is a structural question worth taking seriously before funding a $25k offering with two layers between the investor and the property. A common structure: the investor subscri…
Happening Now
I set up an account on one of the crowdfunding platforms to see what it actually looks like inside. There are two very different things offered and I can't tell what separates the…
Happening Now
Three and a half years into what was sold as a 24 month entitlement play, and there is a capital call notice sitting on my desk. Deal shape: 140 acres of raw ground on the growth…
Discussion
A common structure on these platforms is a target hold of five years with one or two one year extensions at the sponsor's sole option, which in practice means the real commitment…
Win
Take a preferred equity slot in an infill townhome deal on a portal, 25,000 dollars in, 24 month projected term. Say the pref is written as 10 percent per annum on unreturned capi…
Poll
Take two crowdfunding offerings side by side, forcing a real choice between two different kinds of risk. The first is a 140 unit 1980s garden apartment value-add in a Sun Belt sec…
Discussion
Take two offerings on the same platform, same asset, from the same sponsor. One is senior debt at 9 percent fixed, monthly pay, 24 month term. The other is common equity in that b…
Happening Now
I sold a small timber parcel last fall and have about $140k that isn't doing anything. My default is more land, but I've been reading a ground-up industrial flex deal on one of th…
Win
A useful entry point case for real estate crowdfunding is a portal equity deal sized at the platform minimum, say $2,500, into a small retail strip, six bays, one vacant, in a sub…
Poll
Comparing a targeted return from a private deal to a public REIT's dividend yield looks like an apples to apples exercise and rarely is. Take a five year multifamily equity offeri…
Discussion
Say an offering has a $50k minimum, all cash equity, no debt. The sponsor buys 40 acres of raw ground and pursues entitlement for roughly 180 units, then sells the entitled parcel…
Happening Now
Take a common equity position in a ground up multifamily deal on a portal. 48 units, wood frame over podium parking, total capitalization $11.2M. Hard costs come in at $165 a squa…
Loss
The collateral line in the offering read "first priority security interest in 100% of the membership interests of the borrower." I read secured and stopped reading. Nobody was sec…
Poll
I'm three deals into the portals now and the thing I got wrong at the start was spread. My first check was $1,000 into a single value-add multifamily deal because it looked like t…
Win
Consider a $35,000 senior secured position on a 96 unit value add multifamily deal in a mid sized midwest market, raised through a portal. Structure: 11% current pay, monthly, 24…
Discussion
A question from the small investor side. Say someone is saving toward a first purchase and thinking about putting a smaller slice into a crowdfunded deal in the meantime. An agent…
Loss
Here is a case worth studying, because the failure is procedural and it repeats. Take $5,000 into a diversified fund on one of the big portals while the investor builds a list of…
Discussion
Two multifamily deals on one of the bigger portals carry the same gray banner across the invest button: accredited investors only. Plenty of capable investors do not clear that ba…
Happening Now
I've been building a spreadsheet to compare offerings across platforms and it's gotten out of hand, because the headline number is the only thing that's comparable and it's the le…
Poll
Two equity offerings in front of me, same asset type, both targeting low teens IRR on a five year hold. First one: sponsor puts in 10% of the equity alongside investors, 2% acquis…
Poll
A subscription agreement often contains a sentence worth stopping on. The platform describes itself as the portal and the technology provider. The issuer is a separate LLC control…
Poll
Two offerings on the same portal, both multifamily, both roughly four to five year holds, and the distribution structure is the only thing I can't reason my way through. One pays…
Discussion
An offering page will say 10 to 12 percent target IRR and then, further down, carry a line about distributions beginning in year three, which makes no sense to anyone expecting 10…
Happening Now
Third crowdfunded LP position and the first time I've read a waterfall that orders things this way. Language is roughly: distributable cash goes first to an 8% cumulative preferre…
Loss
The plan was diversification. One portal, five deals, $10,000 each, different asset types and different states. Two extended stay hotel conversions, a small industrial infill, a b…
Discussion
Trying to get straight what it actually costs to put money into one of these. One platform says $10 to start, another says $500, and the deal-by-deal ones I looked at said $25,000…
Happening Now
Here is a scenario worth working through for anyone looking at debt offerings on a crowdfunding portal. Take a first position mortgage offering. The minimum is $10,000, the rate i…