Does preferred equity in a crowdfunding deal actually protect me the way I think it does
I keep underwriting deals with a preferred equity structure and telling myself it functions like senior debt because I get paid before common, but the more I read the more I think that comfort is mostly theoretical. The preferred return accrues, sure, but if the sponsor burns through the reserve and the asset sells below what they modeled, the waterfall math I relied on doesn't make me whole, it just makes me first in line to a smaller number. I'm looking at a 32-unit adaptive reuse in Huntsville right now, $50k minimum, 8% pref, 60/40 split above that. The exit underwrite assumes a 5.4 cap in month 48. Huntsville is not a 5.4 cap market in 2025 on a rehabbed product that's not fully stabilized at close. So if the exit cap is actually 6.1 or 6.3, I'm modeling what that does to my recovery and the preferred structure stops feeling protective pretty fast. I'm also not clear on what happens if the senior lender moves before the sponsor can cure. The operating agreement on this one says I have cure rights but I have not found language that tells me what I actually get if I exercise them, like do I step into the deal or do I just get a letter saying thanks for trying. Anyone who has actually been in a preferred equity position when a deal went sideways, what did that protection look like in practice versus what the deal page said it would look like.