Does preferred equity in a crowdfunding deal actually protect me the way I think it does
I keep underwriting deals with a preferred equity structure and telling myself it functions like senior debt because I get paid before common, but the more I read the more I think …
Thread · 7 points
Watched a 1.1M estate sit for 190 days, made contact, got a signed contract at 740k, then couldn't find a buyer with 50k to put down.
Spent about six weeks on that deal. Motivated seller, real condition issues on a 6,400 square foot place outside Memphis, and a price that looked like it had margin in it. I had on…
Thread · 5 points
Does a listing agent have an incentive to price your house to sell fast rather than for the most money
I've been thinking about this a lot lately, specifically because I'm studying the agency side for my exam and I keep running the actual math on what pricing does to an agent's comm…
Thread · 18 points
Does the PR have authority to counter my offer without going back to the heirs first
Trying to work through this on a 1940s fourplex in Tucson I've been underwriting for about six weeks. The personal representative countered my offer at 11k over my number, came bac…
Thread · 13 points
Can you run a property management LLC through a VA-financed fourplex without triggering owner-occupancy issues
I've been picking apart this exact question for about three months because I want to use a VA loan on a fourplex eventually and I also want to keep the business side clean from day…
Thread · 18 points
Someone told me this week that consultants who have not lost money on a deal are just selling theory
A broker I met at a meetup in Fresno said it to me, half joking, while we were talking about a guy who charges $3,500 to review multifamily acquisitions in Phoenix. I laughed at th…
Thread · 14 points
My broker told me a 7 cap today would have been a 5 cap eighteen months ago and now I can't place that number anywhere useful
I've been trying to figure out if that means deals pencil now or if costs moved so much that the spread still doesn't work. Looked at a 48 unit in Tucson last week, asking $4.1M, a…
Thread · 13 points
Does the management company's ADR target align with mine if I'm trying to hold this thing for seven years?
My underwriting on a 44-key select service in Asheville assumes ADR around $148 through 2030, but the operator I'm talking to keeps pitching $165 and says they can get there by yea…
Thread · 13 points
What my broker said about seasonal tenants not actually leaving changed how I'm reading every lease
Had coffee with a broker Friday who's sold maybe a dozen campgrounds in the northeast over the last four years. He said a lot of seasonal tenants at the parks he's moved treat thei…
Thread · 13 points
I let a contractor scope a $148k garage conversion before I found out my city requires owner-occupancy for five years after an ADU permit closes
So that kills the plan where I move out in year two and rent both units. I bought this place in fresno in 2022 for $385k with exactly that exit in mind, primary for a couple years …
Thread · 8 points
Subscription seats or a fee at closing? The second one pays better and drags in licensing
I'm sketching out how a lead platform should get paid and the two ends of the range behave completely differently.
Seats. Say $299 a month per investor for access to a filtered fe…
Thread · 7 points
Client wants to put an IRA into a property I'd be the listing agent on
Getting my license this year and a family friend asked me to help him buy a duplex inside his self-directed Roth. He's serious, has about $340k in the account, and wants to close t…
Thread · 28 points
Exited at 1.58x in month 41, and the certificate of occupancy nearly ate it
The deal was a 68,000 square foot storage facility in a secondary southeast market with a 22,000 foot climate controlled addition to be built on excess pad. Portal deal, accredited…
Thread · 17 points
Four months building an agent brand before I had a license, all wasted
Started posting in June while my coursework was still in progress. The plan was to have an audience ready the day my license came through so I wouldn't be starting from zero.
What…
Thread · 19 points
Moved five properties into LLCs with a document service, cleanup ran $11,300
Portfolio of five, four single family and one duplex, roughly $1.7m of value and $890k of debt across three lenders. I wanted them out of my personal name before I got licensed and…
Thread · 20 points
Somebody wants me pricing a flip before my license clears
Still finishing my licensing coursework, so I can't represent anyone yet, but a friend has asked me to look at a house he wants to flip and tell him what it'll sell for after. He's…
Thread · 24 points
Buyer stopped at month five, and it took 11 months to get the cottage back
Writing this out because everyone told me owner financing was the easy way to sell and I believed them.
Background for anyone new like I was. Seller financing means I sold the hou…
Thread · 25 points
Both listings run from my Airbnb account, with payouts landing in my bank
Contract is sitting in front of me for Friday. Two units, same owner, both already operating with a year of history I can see in the exports.
Unit A, 2BR condo walking distance to…
Thread · 25 points
Does originating loans for other people's money make me a broker in my state?
Working on my salesperson license now and a private lender I know suggested I bring him deals and take a piece of the points. He funds, I find the borrower, walk the file, and get …
Thread · 20 points
What does a one-person title shop pay to open the door?
I'm sitting for my licensing and trying to build a real startup number instead of a guess. So far I have the state title insurance producer license exam and fee, an underwriter app…
Thread · 15 points
Manage boarding houses for owners, or get licensed and own one room at a time
Halfway through getting licensed and the boarding house owners I've met keep pushing me in two directions.
One path is third party management. Fee is typically higher than convent…
Thread · 14 points
How hard can I push on consent rights before the operator walks
Working through a first JV structure on a value-add deal. $4.5M of equity, my side $4M, operator $500k, 8% pref then 50/50. I asked for consent on sale, refinance, any new debt, th…
Thread · 23 points
Turning down homeowner kitchens to keep two slots open for investor rehabs
License paperwork is nearly through and I have two directions in front of me that I can't run at the same time with three guys.
Direction one is investor work only. Repeat clients…
Thread · 9 points
Single-asset QOF where you can see the building, or a pooled multi-asset fund?
Reading two offerings side by side and they're barely the same product.
One is a single-asset QOF, 88 units, one tract, sponsor is local and has built four of these. I can drive t…
Thread · 27 points
I was answering the inbox the week distributions got paused
The sponsor I do part time admin work for paused distributions on a 190 unit value add in the second week of the quarter. I'd been hired to keep the investor CRM tidy and to format…
Thread · 31 points
Is there any licensing or insurance side to buying REIT shares?
Studying for my license now and most of the material is about representing buyers and sellers. Nothing in it touches REITs, which made me wonder whether buying them for my own acco…
Thread · 20 points
Every worked BRRRR example starts with money the writer already had
Getting my license and doing a lot of reading on the side, and BRRRR keeps coming up as the thing people do when they don't have much money. But every worked example I find starts …
Thread · 15 points
Took a leasing seat on a 312-unit lease-up and asked for the weekly report
I wanted the license for brokerage originally. Then I got offered a leasing consultant seat at a lease-up, 312 units delivering in four phases, and took it because I figured I'd le…
Thread · 38 points
The fund offered me $15k of the same note I'd be valuing
I'm partway through licensing and a small fund that buys defaulted paper asked whether I'd do their exterior valuations in my county. Flat $125 per report, photos, condition notes,…
Thread · 32 points
Twelve positions in one year, or four a year for three years
I've got a sleeve I want to put into crowdfunded deals over time, and the sequencing is where I keep stalling. Not the amount, the pacing.
One way: pick a couple of platforms, tak…
Thread · 12 points
Does the option period clock pause if the property sits in probate mid-term
Eight months of heir disagreement before you even have a signed agreement means you have no option at all yet, so nothing is eating into anything. The 24-month window starts when b…
Reply · 4 points
When a seller accepts your price immediately, what does that tell you about where you set it?
The ARV minus stack is what I use on paper, but I have no closed deals to test it against yet, so I want to push back on the opening post from the other direction. You are framing …
Reply · 3 points
What actually happens to a development's equity waterfall when certificate of occupancy slips by six months
The part that gets glossed over is what happens to the construction loan extension fee when you're already telegraphing a six-month slip to your lender but haven't said anything fo…
Reply · 8 points
The emergency-call system vendor wanted a seven-year term on a 72-unit deal, and the early-termination clause was buried in the exhibits.
@ryanmck27 here, still on the acquiring side of nothing yet, but I underwrite a lot of senior stuff in Tucson and this thread is making me re-examine the vendor schedule line in ev…
Reply · 6 points
My cleanout vendor told me he makes more per hour on my jobs than I do and I cannot figure out if he is wrong
The $4,200 projected is doing a lot of work in that sentence. What does it drop to if the ARV comes in 8% low or the hold stretches to nine months? Because that is the number that …
Reply · 12 points
Does a hotel operator's earnout structure actually protect me or just delay the conversation we were always going to have
The comp set problem is the whole thing here and you named it exactly right. When the operator runs their own trailing 12 during a period their two closest comps were half-staffed,…
Reply · 8 points
Does anyone else have a CRM that runs perfectly and a pipeline that still feels broken
You marked it "needs follow-up" and the automation just sat there waiting politely. The system did its job and you still ghosted the seller, so yeah, that's the answer to your ques…
Reply · 10 points
Parking ratios zoned for 1990s office use are adding six figures to conversion budgets before a shovel moves.
What's the existing lot's ownership structure, fee simple with the office parcel or a shared easement?
Reply · 13 points
Twelve units is where the feasibility math changes character and most builders underestimate how much it changes.
What cap rate does your bulk buyer actually quote you in that market right now?
Reply · 9 points
Wild deed restriction from 1954 shows up as an exception and nobody at the table can say whether it still binds
Nobody has asked what "storage of goods for sale" actually meant in 1954 versus how a court reads it today, because that language has a lot of room in it. Running an Etsy operation…
Reply · 12 points
My agent sent me a coordination agreement and I cannot figure out what she is actually responsible for if a deadline slips
@OP the "don't worry" reply over email is actually the part I'd screenshot and save, because if something blows up she said it in writing even if it wasn't a formal amendment.
The…
Reply · 12 points
Did the estate ever actually own the property or did it pass outside probate
The attorney treating it like a standard probate sale is the part that would make me stop. In Arizona a funded revocable trust bypasses the personal representative entirely, so if …
Reply · 11 points
The abatement burn rate on a triple net office lease deserves its own line item, and most models I look at treat it as a footnote.
Phantom NOI inflating exit value by $3.4M is the exact number that should be on page one of the deck, not buried in a rent schedule tab.
What year does the promote trigger, relati…
Reply · 15 points
The seller's insurance policy cancels at closing and nobody has a plan
My title company caught nothing on that front, it was entirely self-managed. The one thing I'd push back on slightly is the framing around force-placed coverage as the worst outcom…
Reply · 15 points
Would you actually live in the thing while you're rehabbing it
The vagueness from your broker when you asked about the lender piece is the whole story right there. When a deal structure actually holds up, people can explain it in two sentences…
Reply · 14 points
The buyer's inspector flagged a 40-year-old copper repipe on a finished 2.9M house and the buyer wants a 280k credit three days before closing.
The disclosure question is the one I'd be staring at too, because if the repipe showed up in the seller's disclosure and the buyer's agent signed off on it, that attorney's leverag…
Reply · 6 points
Does a certificate of need state actually slow down the supply problem enough to matter for a 6-bed RAL
What's the actual census vacancy rate for licensed RALs within ten miles of that property?
Reply · 3 points
Has anyone here bought their first rental while still technically enrolled
The 710 to 760 rate difference is real but on a small duplex that spread is maybe 25 to 50 basis points, which matters more in a 7-percent-rate environment than people think. I'm s…
Reply · 12 points
My transactional funder charged me 2,400 on a 14,200 spread and I thought that was the market rate until I shopped three others and the lowest came in at 900.
Habit is genuinely expensive and this is a good example of exactly how much. My question is whether the $900 funder caps out at a loan amount that stops working once your spreads g…
Reply · 6 points
Does the note I carry on a probate sale price differently because the chain of title ran through an estate
Eight months of ownership is going to cost you a discount, probably 3 to 5 points on top of whatever seasoning hit you already expected.
Reply · 8 points
The renovation line I did not expect to matter most was the one nobody sees
The knob-and-tube discovery mid-project is exactly the scenario that makes me skeptical of any inspection contingency that gets waived or truncated to win a bid. I'm underwriting d…
Reply · 12 points
Buying down the rate on an investment property costs more than the same move on a primary, and most people run the math wrong
@ryanmck27 here, studying for the exam and running numbers on deals I don't own yet, so take this for what it's worth.
The 32 percent marginal rate assumption is doing a lot of wo…
Reply · 12 points
My platform just showed a $0.00 distribution on a deal that collected 14% in fees before I saw a dollar.
Non-subordinated fees on a 26-month overrun with zero investor distributions is exactly why I underwrite the fee stack before I read anything else now.
Reply · 3 points
DSCR got you the building, now the owner-occupant rules are gone and everything changes
The lender's appraisal on the unit you're occupying is probably not what you think it is. On a DSCR deal the appraiser fills out a rent schedule for every unit, and that number bec…
Reply · 10 points
Sellers who will not move are usually protecting something that never made it into the negotiation
Saw one deal in 2023 where the seller's hard line was covering a HELOC they'd taken out eighteen months prior.
Reply · 14 points
The buyer who never shows on a dispo blast is often the one actually buying in your market
Who told you the eight off-list buyers want to be found?
Reply · 9 points
The contact rate is not the number to fix when the real problem is list decay
Six percent to one percent over three passes on the same 1,800 records is basically a controlled experiment proving the list is dead, and the vendor still called it market softness…
Reply · 15 points
The rent-to-PITI ratio at conversion looks very different depending on whether the owner-occupant put 3.5 percent down or 10 percent down at purchase.
The $2,600 PITI figure is probably still optimistic on the insurance side if you're in a state with any weather exposure. I'm seeing landlord policies in Tucson running $150 to $18…
Reply · 18 points
Paid a hedged agency mREIT a 14 percent yield and still came out behind a 5 percent savings account over 18 months
What was your expected hold when you entered, were you modeling this as a 3 plus year position?
Reply · 14 points
How do I tell whether a commercial buyer who asked for a second look is actually re-evaluating or just stalling me out
Ask each of them for a number by Friday, even a soft range.
Reply · 16 points