If my listing agent brings a buyer do I save the buy-side commission or does it just go to the same person
Closing on the Akron duplex in about three weeks and already thinking about what happens if I ever sell it. The listing agreement I signed for the Cleveland condo has a cooperating…
Thread · 13 points
I bought with a number in my head and the number was wrong before I even closed
Bought a condo in Cleveland, 2022, priced it off what I thought the market would do in 18 months. I was not accounting for what I would actually net after the HOA assessment that h…
Thread · 15 points
My title company just asked me if I have a "local presence" and I don't know what that actually means
Came up in a call Tuesday. I'm working a potential deal in a market I've never been to, and the title company rep stopped me mid-sentence and said something like, "do you have a lo…
Thread · 17 points
Does the agent owe me anything in writing before I commit to working with them exclusively
Closing on a duplex in Akron in about three weeks and the agent I used wants me to sign a six-month exclusivity agreement before she'll send me anything else. I get why she wants t…
Thread · 23 points
My Akron duplex closes in six weeks and I already made the mistake of anchoring to replacement cost as a safety net
I kept reading the 240-unit Sun Belt thread and nodding along, and then I went back to the actual deal I am about to be involved in and realized I had done the same thing without n…
Thread · 12 points
My reserve line on the Akron duplex is 4 percent of gross rents and I have no idea if that transfers to how I should think about reserves on a crowdfunded deal
Been staring at this since I signed the purchase agreement. On the duplex I budgeted about $180 a month into reserves, which is roughly 4 percent of what the two units should bring…
Thread · 10 points
My sponsor on the Akron duplex said something offhand about STR analysis that I cannot get out of my head
He said the number that kills first-time STR buyers is not the occupancy estimate, it is the gap between occupied nights and paid nights after platform fees, cleaning reimbursement…
Thread · 14 points
My seller just got a $3.1M cash offer and wants to counter at $3.4M because her neighbor sold for $3.35M in 2022
I watched her pull up that comp herself on her phone. The 2022 sale was a full reno, corner lot, finished basement. Hers has the original kitchen and has been sitting 61 days. I do…
Thread · 13 points
Does the inspector's job end when he hands me the report or is he supposed to walk me through it
My Akron closing is in 19 days and the inspector I hired sent me a 58-page PDF at 9:47 PM with no call, no summary, nothing. I have been reading it for three hours and I am genuine…
Thread · 9 points
My listing agent has gone six months without one showing update unless I text first
So I'm on the passive side and still in the prep phase, not selling anything yet, but I bought a small condo in Cleveland last year thinking I might list it this spring. Hired an a…
Thread · 9 points
Does a cleanout estimate before closing actually change what I offer on the property
Closing in about six weeks on a duplex in Akron, 1940s build, previous tenant left two years ago. The listing photos show furniture, bags, a full garage. I have not walked it yet. …
Thread · 15 points
Can I sell the note I'm carrying before the balloon hits
Bought a fourplex in akron last year, carried the paper at 8% with a 7 year balloon, and I'm already wondering if I could sell this note to someone in year 2 or 3 if I needed the c…
Thread · 4 points
Maintenance capex is 4% of revenue in one filing and 11% in another
I've been reading through public filings for the listed data center owners because I wanted to understand what a passive holder actually pays out of the rent before anything reache…
Thread · 15 points
What does a VA agency actually do that I couldn't do by hiring someone myself
I'm reading through service businesses in real estate and this one confuses me more than the others.
The agency doesn't own anything and doesn't do the work. They find a person, t…
Thread · 40 points
Two 5-units, same price: one full at market, one where every tenant is 200 under
I've read the section on income valuation twice and I think I finally understand why these two buildings are asking the same number. Both are 5 units, same small city, about a mile…
Thread · 17 points
$1,000 to start, and I don't know what the two buttons on the platform do
I set up an account on one of the crowdfunding platforms to see what it actually looks like inside. There are two very different things offered and I can't tell what separates them…
Thread · 11 points
After six weeks of vendor proposals the per-lead math never works
I've been reading vendor proposals for six weeks and I want someone to poke at the arithmetic before I sign anything.
Vendor A prices per delivered lead. $75 for what they call a …
Thread · 36 points
The 70 percent rule keeps giving me a max purchase price that's below every listing I look at
I've been running the formula on everything in a 20 mile radius. ARV times 0.70, minus repairs, and that's the most I can pay.
On a house listed at 189 where I think ARV is 250 an…
Thread · 17 points
The second lender came in 0.375 lower. Here's what changed.
I've been planning this purchase for over a year and financing was the part I was most afraid of, so I want to write down what actually happened.
Small three bedroom, $268,000 pur…
Thread · 17 points
The interest reserve made the note look current right up to the payoff statement
I lent 50k as a second position note into a BRRRR on a small single family, 12 percent, interest only, 12 month term, repaid from the refinance. Monthly interest arrived on time ev…
Thread · 37 points
Exit cap 15 basis points above entry, five year hold. Which line do you break first?
I've been reading two offering models side by side for a week and the thing that keeps stopping me is the terminal value.
Deal one: 200 units, entry cap 5.1, exit cap 5.25 at the …
Thread · 35 points
Signed a 45-day, one-county agreement and closed inside it at 289k
The first draft the agent handed me was 12 months, the whole state, 3 percent. I read it twice, then read it a third time, and the part that bothered me wasn't the percent. It was …
Thread · 31 points
The part of a tiered commission where the tier actually paid
I sold the condo I'd lived in for nine years to fund the thing I'm slowly building. Because I read everything twice, I asked all three agents whether they'd do a tiered structure a…
Thread · 16 points
Appraisal-based index numbers and what the 6.9 percent is actually measuring
I read the NCREIF timberland volatility figure three times before it bothered me. Around 6.9 percent standard deviation against roughly 16 for public equities, and the properties i…
Thread · 26 points
LP positions inside a self-directed retirement account, or keep them taxable
I've been reading the same argument in two directions for weeks and I want to hear it from people who've actually done it.
The case for using a self-directed IRA: syndications tak…
Thread · 18 points
If the license line keeps moving, is double closing the answer or just a more expensive way to be wrong?
I've been reading through the 2025 state changes and the pattern that jumps out is that most of them attach to marketing and to the fact that the wholesaler doesn't own the propert…
Thread · 34 points
With AVMs eating the $300 to $600 work, is the complex stuff enough to live on
Two numbers in this room don't fit together for me. A single family appraisal is $300 to $600, and AVMs or property condition reports already sit on something like 35 to 45 percent…
Thread · 19 points
The acceleration language in this wrap note draft works backwards
Not doing a deal. Somebody in a local group shared an anonymized wrap note and deed of trust package as a teaching example and I've been going through it clause by clause, which is…
Thread · 10 points
Do you underwrite every certificate as a property purchase, or price it purely for yield?
Reading this room for a few weeks and there are two clearly different practices in it and both are defended by people who've done more than I have.
The first says: most certificat…
Thread · 19 points
Redfin says luxury buyer-agent commissions ticked down. On a $5M sale does that even register?
The finding I can't stop turning over: after the new rules, buyer-agent commission percentages on high-end homes drifted slightly lower while the more affordable end held or went u…
Thread · 35 points
The contract seller wanted 70 percent of a $38k spread and thought that was generous because he found the deal.
When they bring a partial list I want to know how many names on it actually closed in the last eighteen months.
Reply · 0 points
My first capital raise is probably two deals away and I am already tripping over what to put in an update
The framing question is the right one but I think you are asking it backwards. The memo is not where you manage that line, the subscription call or the first conversation is. If an…
Reply · 7 points
DSCR loans treat the property as the borrower, and that changes what you can do with the structure
@kevin_lombard wait, that is me posting. The refinance-to-deploy math is what I keep running back over because that post-refi DSCR check is the part that bites people. I am about t…
Reply · 11 points
My crowdfunding deal in Sacramento just hit month 19 and the IRR projection assumes a sale at a cap rate that hasn't existed in this market since 2021
The 1990s vintage detail is the part people are glossing over. That stock in Sacramento is trading at a discount to the cleaner 2000s product even when cap rates are equal on paper…
Reply · 15 points
Dual agency on a commercial deal where the seller carry terms matter more than the price
Balloon term is what I'd be staring at hardest. A five-year balloon sounds fine until rates are still ugly in year four and you're shopping a refi on a property the seller knows be…
Reply · 13 points
Lakewood ranch is finally making money and it took three extra months of carrying costs to get here
@OP_Lakewood the line about losing six weeks on the chain of people rather than the beam itself is exactly the thing nobody told me before I started. My Akron duplex isn't a flip b…
Reply · 16 points
My comps on a dispo deal last week came in $23k under what the contract seller gave me, and I still moved it.
The one thing I never see work is pushing a buyer to commit before they have talked to their own contractor, because when rehab blows past the number, they remember exactly who hur…
Reply · 10 points
Pomegranate acreage is priced like a mature orchard crop and behaves more like a startup
The cap rate math in the original post is solid but the variance window is actually wider than 8 to 11 percent implies, because that range assumes costs are fixed when they are not…
Reply · 8 points
My first syndication as GP closes in 11 days and I have already spent $61,000 I will not get back if it falls apart.
The historic tax credit overlay is what broke the cost model for you, and I do not think sponsors who have not touched HTC deals understand how differently those diligence layers s…
Reply · 16 points
Memphis my first wholesaling go
What's the actual rent in place right now, signed lease or vacant?
Reply · 12 points
The ADU rental income looks clean on paper until the lender treats it as a future unit with no history
180 basis points more and a floating rate they never modeled, that detail alone should be in every ADU pro forma by default.
What was the HELOC rate at draw versus the original co…
Reply · 13 points
My best probate deal this year came from a PR who had already fired one investor
The 34k padded to 40k before anything went to paper is the move I keep trying to train myself to do and keep talking myself out of. I did a scope estimate on a condo situation in C…
Reply · 12 points
Does anyone track land bank parcels by utility district expansion schedules rather than proximity to city limits
Funded extension still doesn't mean the parcel gets served on the timeline you're planning around. I bought into a CIP window in Portage County, Ohio around 2021, district had a bi…
Reply · 7 points
Did the cleanout crew invoice me for a second trip I never authorized
What did your PM think his authorization limit actually was?
Reply · 14 points
My attorney said "the intercreditor agreement is your brokerage's operating agreement" and I cannot stop thinking about whether that maps
The GP deal you described where the check came back empty is exactly what scared me into reading every waterfall clause twice before I sign anything on the passive side. What kills…
Reply · 7 points
Floor plate depth is the conversion variable I see mispriced more often than any other single line item.
Municipals are sleeping on this in Cleveland right now. The city is dangling adaptive reuse incentives for the downtown office stock and every pro forma I have seen floating around…
Reply · 16 points
Does anybody know if it's cheaper to use a licensed surveyor before or after you get the county plat approval process started in Georgia
The $4,800 upfront feels like it's solving the wrong problem first. If the county won't approve 6-9 lots on that acreage under their current zoning or minimum lot size rules, no pl…
Reply · 14 points
The sector a REIT operates in explains less of the return than most people expect once you account for balance sheet quality.
Sector thesis is how I find the room, balance sheet is whether I stay.
I priced my Cleveland condo based on comps and ignored carrying costs, lost about $4,800 in the first eight …
Reply · 16 points
The seller's insurance policy cancels at closing and nobody has a plan
Did your carrier know the loan was staying in the seller's name?
Reply · 8 points
Does anyone here treat the fund manager's track record outside OZ as more predictive than anything in the offering doc
The 2031 exit sensitivity table is one of those things I have never seen actually predict what happens. What I see instead is that sponsors build the sale assumption around what ma…
Reply · 15 points
Has anyone actually mapped where their land notes sit on the credit curve and done anything with that information
@kevin_lombard would probably read this differently than I do since I'm on the passive side, but the fund offering you 79 on Ohio and 71 on New Mexico is telling you something pret…
Reply · 12 points
Paying off the mortgage early versus buying the next property is a question that looks like personal finance but is really a spread trade
The all-cash underwrite is the part most people skip, and I skipped it too until I started running numbers on the Akron duplex. When I stripped the financing out, the cap rate came…
Reply · 14 points
The cleanout is done and the estate attorney says the abandoned furniture belongs to heirs who have not responded in four months.
The indemnification language point is the one that gets glossed over every time, and when the vendor's boilerplate protects the vendor and nobody else, the buyer finds out the hard…
Reply · 12 points
The spread everybody quotes is the one before the contract seller's number gets confirmed
What exit is the buyer actually planning when they close at your number?
Reply · 14 points
When a municipality rezones a corridor mid-entitlement, who actually owns the upside
The part about the seller letting the option lapse by not cooperating on a title condition, that is exactly what happened with a deal I was watching in Lakewood. Fixed price, selle…
Reply · 19 points
The seller accepted my number, the buyer backed out at the net sheet, and the deal died on a line item I never thought to ask about.
What county were you in, because transfer tax variance alone can swing $800 to $2,400 on a $112k deal depending on municipality.
Reply · 15 points
Single-family homes are showing up in NNN structures more often than most people in this room expect, and the mechanics are worth thinking through carefully.
The carpet and subfloor thing in Euclid is exactly what I am afraid of with the Akron duplex if I ever tried to structure something like this. A group home operator specifically is…
Reply · 14 points
A $3.8M buyer asked me to pull the permit history before we wrote the offer, and what came back changed the price conversation entirely
What municipality are we talking about, because retroactive permit timelines vary wildly?
Reply · 17 points
DSCR spreads over conventional do not compress the way people expect when rates rise
The 300k example landed for me because I am literally staring at numbers like that on my Akron duplex right now. What nobody pulled apart yet is what happens to your DSCR ratio its…
Reply · 8 points
Staging a house where the price reduction already happened and the stager wants a fresh fee to try again
What was the days-on-market average for comparable vacant listings in that zip during the same 61 days?
Reply · 11 points