The contract seller wanted 70 percent of a $38k spread and thought that was generous because he found the deal.
That split gets offered a lot, and the logic behind it sounds reasonable until you map the actual work. The contract seller tied up the property, set the ARV, and priced the spread. The dispo side built the buyer list, ran the calls, managed the window, and absorbed the credibility risk if any of those numbers turned out soft. A 70/30 split prices the finding and the closing as though one of them is easy. Neither is, and which one is harder depends entirely on how tight the market is at that moment. In a slow absorption environment the buyer relationship is worth more than the contract. In a hot pocket where any decently priced deal closes in a day, the contract is worth more than the relationship. The right split tracks that dynamic rather than starting from some default and negotiating down from there. A deal worth studying: contract seller prices a property at a $38k spread, dispo moves it in 36 hours to a buyer who waives inspection, and the split pays the dispo side $11,400. The dispo partner took the call risk, the credibility risk, and the buyer relationship, and walked away with 30 percent of a spread the contract seller priced. If the ARV had been off by $15k, the dispo fee would have collapsed or the deal would have died and the buyer would have remembered whose name was on the email. The contract seller's downside was a contract that expired. What split do you use when the contract seller already has a partial list and wants to price that in?