The phrase means different things depending on who is asking it, so let me separate the two versions.
From a title company's side, "local presence" usually means: is there someone physically reachable who can handle things that need to happen in person? That includes walking the property to confirm its condition, meeting a seller who cannot do everything digitally, and sometimes receiving documents. A contact who does walkthroughs fits that description. Your answer was probably fine.
The second version is a compliance question. Some states require a licensed real estate agent to be involved when a contract is being assigned, or they impose disclosure rules on wholesalers operating from out of state. If the title company works mainly with local investors, she may have been quietly checking whether you understood the rules in that market, even if she did not say so directly.
Here is the thing you did not ask, and it matters: "local presence" is not a defined legal standard with a single national definition. What satisfies it in one state may not in another. The strategy guide for virtual wholesaling calls multistate regulatory divergence one of the main risks of this model, and that is exactly what you are sitting in right now.
Two things I would do before your next call with that title company. First, ask her directly what she needs to feel comfortable closing a remote deal. Title companies see a lot of transactions and most will tell you plainly. Second, run the specific state through a real estate attorney who practices there, not a general one, because the rules vary and a licensing question needs a licensed professional's answer.
You did not sound lost in that call. You had an answer. The gap is just knowing what the bar actually is in that specific state.
What state is the deal in? That changes what I can point you to in the guide.