Does a QOF sponsor's ability to exit a prior deal on time tell you more than their underwriting ever will
I've been sitting with about $190k in capital gains from the fourplex sale and I've been reading offering docs for three months now. The underwriting in most of them is fine, I gue…
Thread · 13 points
My bird dog contract says 30 days from delivery but my investor is dragging escrow past 60
Does the standard move here to extend the window in writing, or do most people just renegotiate the fee when this happens?
Thread · 7 points
Airbnb just changed how cancellations work and I need to rethink my numbers before I wire anything into this space
I was already close to pulling the trigger on a small cabin outside Hocking Hills, asking $285k, and had rough STR projections built around a moderate cancellation buffer, maybe 8 …
Thread · 5 points
Has anyone actually made money owning the land under a small home community long term
Sold my Canton fourplex last fall and I am sitting on about $190k waiting for the right place to put it, and I keep coming back to land-lease communities with compact homes. Not th…
Thread · 22 points
Does a wholesaler's ARV even matter if my rehab budget is the variable that actually moves
Selling a fourplex in Canton right now and sitting on cash for the first time in a while, so I've been going through a lot of deals that wholesalers are sending me in the Akron and…
Thread · 13 points
Someone told me my landing page headline is the reason my opt-in rate is low, but I have no way to know if that is actually true
Selling a fourplex in Canton right now so I have been spending the last few weeks figuring out where the cash goes next, and part of that is finally looking hard at what a seller l…
Thread · 16 points
Has anyone actually recovered a prime-season week after a late cancellation, and what did it cost you to do it
I have a cabin owner I'm talking to about co-hosting and she lost a full week in July two summers ago, a Saturday-to-Saturday booking that cancelled nine days out. She said she re-…
Thread · 10 points
My JV partner said he never signs anything until he's heard the seller's voice twice
Had a call with him Thursday about a potential deal in Massillon, maybe six miles from where my fourplex sits. He said most deals fall apart at the seller, not the buyer, and he wo…
Thread · 14 points
Does anyone run student beds near a school that's been losing enrollment for three or four years straight, or do you just avoid that entirely?
I'm looking at a 12-bed setup about six blocks from a mid-size Ohio university that's been down roughly 8 percent headcount since 2020. Seller is pricing it like enrollment stabili…
Thread · 19 points
My LP position in a 188 unit Phoenix deal just got marked down 40 percent and I don't know what to do with that number
Got the update last week. Sponsor reappraised at $28.4M, bought in at a valuation implying closer to $47M two years ago. Tucson and Scottsdale vintage I've looked at since are pric…
Thread · 13 points
Does a 3D scan of a building I haven't visited actually tell me anything useful
Guy I know who buys multifamily in Tulsa told me this week that he paid $420 for a Matterport scan of a 12-unit before flying out, and it caught a layout problem that would have ch…
Thread · 21 points
Does the note I carry stay private or does it show up somewhere public
Closing on a fourplex in canton ohio next month, seller financing the buyer for 187k at 8% with a 5 year balloon. My attorney mentioned the mortgage gets recorded but I didn't thin…
Thread · 1 point
I funded the first leg and the end buyer's wire never came. I owned the house for five months.
First and last time I played transactional lender without checking the far end of the chain.
Deal came to me from a wholesaler I'd done nothing with before, referred by someone I …
Thread · 21 points
Same 60k: a listed REIT sleeve I can sell on a Tuesday, or eight private deals I can't touch for five years
I've got 60k that's earmarked for real estate exposure and no operating role in it either way, so the question is purely which wrapper.
Option A is listed REITs. Daily pricing, se…
Thread · 21 points
One agent has off-market deals and weak numbers. The other has the opposite.
I've got money set aside for a first small multifamily and I've now interviewed two agents who both call themselves investor focused.
The first one brought me three properties tha…
Thread · 18 points
Sold 34 acres on my own paper, and the partial release clause almost killed it
Closed three weeks ago on 34 acres of raw land I'd sat on for nine years, no debt against it, taxes about 1,400 a year.
Price 168k, buyer put 25% down (42k), I carry 126k at 8.5%,…
Thread · 11 points
Put $75k into a development LP and learned what a capital call is the expensive way
Writing this for people at my level, which is the level where you read the deck and think you understand it.
Two and a half years ago I put $75k into a 60 unit ground-up apartment…
Thread · 23 points
Price the parking income or the dirt, and what if they disagree?
Looking at two deals in the same mid-size downtown and they've forced a question I can't resolve cleanly.
Deal A: 180-space surface lot, two blocks from a hospital campus. Trailin…
Thread · 11 points
The rent bump schedule is what made a 7.4 sale-leaseback work
Closed six weeks ago on an 8,300 sf small-format discount retail building in a town of about 4,500 in the upper midwest. Corporate lease, investment-grade parent guaranty, 13 years…
Thread · 15 points
Listing agent worked both sides of a 9-unit for a flat dollar fee
The listing agreement on this one was 5% and the agent already had me walking the building before it hit the wire, so she wanted dual agency from the first showing. I said yes, wit…
Thread · 38 points
I lost $4,400 without ever owning a note
Worth writing down because everything I'd read about this strategy assumes you get to the closing.
A seller was breaking up a small tape and I bid on three files out of it. To mov…
Thread · 38 points
1.5 and 20 against 2 and 20. Which one am I actually being paid for?
I have $200k I'm ready to place and two funds in front of me. I've never been in a fund before, only two small LP positions in single-property deals.
Fund A: $75M value-add multif…
Thread · 31 points
Operator co-invest or operator track record, which one carries more weight when you can only really verify one
Two operators approached me in the same month and I can't have both, so I've been sitting with what actually separates them.
Operator A wants to put in 15% of the equity out of hi…
Thread · 15 points
Does the lot rent gap or the expense ratio sell the sector to a first-time LP?
I've been reading two different pitch decks for park funds and they lead with completely different things.
The first one spends four pages on lot rents being $340 in the target ma…
Thread · 12 points
If I put money behind one dispo operation, do I back the buyer list or the distribution software?
I've been sitting with two pitches from people who both call themselves dispo shops, and they're built on opposite bets.
The first one is a woman with about 60 buyers she talks to…
Thread · 26 points
My refinance came back with no appraisal at all, which took me two days to believe
Refinancing a small rental I've owned a while. I had budgeted for the appraisal, maybe five hundred, and I'd blocked out an afternoon to be there.
Then the loan officer emails and…
Thread · 27 points
The fee math on 62 leads only worked because of one rule I set
I started scouting to meet the people I eventually want to place money with, and I kept records the whole way because I wasn't sure the activity paid for itself. Seven months later…
Thread · 38 points
One ledger with property classes, or a separate file per entity. The books I read split about even
I've gone through the books of four operators this year while deciding where to put money, and the split was two and two.
Two of them ran everything in a single accounting file wi…
Thread · 30 points
Does the fund fee make sense against doing it myself with $400k?
Sitting on $400,000 earmarked for something with predictable cash behavior, and certificates keep coming back as the answer because the return is written into statute rather than n…
Thread · 17 points
Committed capital or pledge fund for a first-time manager
Been comparing two emerging manager structures side by side and they solve the same problem in opposite directions.
Structure one is a real blind pool. Investors sign an LPA, comm…
Thread · 16 points
Signed my first ever NDA on a commercial deal and I do not even own anything yet
What was the land acquisition cost baked into that $890k?
Reply · -1 point
My county says one ADU per lot and my neighbor has three permitted ones stacked on a corner parcel
The permit sequence is exactly what the current-status database hides, and I've only ever found it one way: you ask the clerk to run the parcel history report from the building dep…
Reply · 3 points
My transactional funder wants to see a recorded deed before releasing funds on leg B and I don't understand how that is supposed to work same-day.
Your trainer's non-answer is the part that bugged me reading this. "Your title company handles it" is true but it skips the part where you need to know *which* title company, becau…
Reply · 4 points
My stager just told me she prices the neighborhood, not the house, and I have been turning that over for three days
@11,400 is about 0.54% of list price, which is roughly in line with what I've heard from people playing in that bracket. What I'd want to know before signing anything is whether th…
Reply · 9 points
Payout ratio versus FFO payout ratio in a REIT filing, and they rarely land in the same place
AFFO is where I spend most of my time, because recurring capex assumptions are where management gets creative.
Reply · 5 points
Does a cleanout subcontractor carry your liability exposure when something goes wrong on a foreclosure property
Who signed off on the disposal decision before the crew ever walked in?
Reply · 7 points
Off-market Milwaukee park data is thin enough that most of what circulates is priced for a buyer who cannot find anything better
The GIS layer pull is right but the DSPS database lag is not just an inconvenience, it ran eight months behind on a community in Waukesha County that I was tracking in late 2023, m…
Reply · 14 points
My operator is reforecasting the exit cap rate six months before close and the new number changes my return by 40 points
What's the operator's current asking rent on vacant units versus what they underwrote at origination, because if rents came in close to pro forma the 6.2 cap is harder to justify o…
Reply · 12 points
My office deal looked passive until the anchor started hot-desking half its space six months before renewal
That line about being deep in the Conroe close is the one that stuck with me, because attention is finite and office will always find the moment you've allocated it somewhere else.…
Reply · 6 points
My first driving for dollars find that I actually closed on came from a street I almost skipped
That $35,500 net on a $61k buy is a reasonable outcome but I want to know what your holding costs looked like because four months of carrying a vacant property in Tulsa with $22k o…
Reply · 16 points
Does the coach who made money in 2011 to 2019 actually know what this market punishes
The gap I actually care about is whether they ever had a deal fall apart mid-contract because conditions shifted, not whether they closed a lot of deals. Closing volume from 2013 t…
Reply · 11 points
Does a listing agent have an incentive to price your house to sell fast rather than for the most money
The math you ran is exactly right and Levitt wrote about it in 2005 using Chicago MLS data. Agents left their own homes on market nine days longer and sold for about 3.7% more than…
Reply · 7 points
The pref investor who read the waterfall wrong and the sponsor who wrote it wrong can share the same document
@op that $2.24M against $1.95M recoverable is where it stops being a documentation dispute and becomes a math problem with no exit. Legally current, economically gone, and the remo…
Reply · 12 points
Twelve units is where the feasibility math changes character and most builders underestimate how much it changes.
@reba_finch09 wrote "the interest reserve on a construction loan that runs 18 to 24 months is a real line item" and yes, but the number people get wrong is what happens when the dr…
Reply · 9 points
Someone just told me a bird dog should get paid at closing, not per lead, because it aligns incentives, and I can see the logic but I'm not sure it holds.
The two-part model is fine in theory but I have never once seen the second payment survive a serious dispute about lead quality. What happens instead is the bird dog starts arguing…
Reply · 11 points
Can a housing authority approve a rent increase above what the market is clearing and should I even want that
What zip codes are you actually looking at in Memphis?
Reply · 11 points
Did the estate ever actually own the property or did it pass outside probate
@the poster what does the signature block on the listing agreement actually say, does the PR sign as PR or as trustee, because I've seen attorneys paper over exactly this ambiguity…
Reply · 11 points
Owner-occupied multifamily in Charlotte: the unit mix and the numbers that decide whether this works
What percentage of your PITI do the two rented units actually cover in Charlotte right now?
Reply · 9 points
6.8 percent cap on a 22,000 sf building, one tenant, lease expiring in 19 months.
The 19 months feels like the whole story to me, and I would not buy the building, I would buy an option on the building if the seller would sit still for it. Six months of exclusiv…
Reply · 14 points
The seller contact came in on Friday and by Monday my partner had already called the title company without looping me in.
Mine doesn't name a coordinator either, but what I've never seen work is settling it verbally deal by deal. People remember those conversations differently when there's $8k on the …
Reply · 17 points
My buyer just asked if he can pay me 6 percent and I said yes without doing the math first
The thing I have never seen work is a seller who quotes a coupon rate, realizes mid-deal it is not the same as yield, and then tries to renegotiate the rate upward after the buyer …
Reply · 13 points
Small multifamily operators sometimes structure a deal that pays them whether you profit or not
Got marked down 40 percent as an LP in Phoenix partly because I never asked this question.
Reply · 13 points
When a builder walks a finished lot and says the price does not work, what number are they actually protecting
Ask them what their current cost-per-door is on the last closed project, not the one they're quoting you.
Reply · 7 points
Has anyone gotten a lead worth calling just from showing up to a property and talking to a neighbor?
Happened to me on a duplex in Massillon, neighbor told me the owner had moved to Florida and hated managing it from there.
Reply · 14 points
Sold a wholesale contract on a Phoenix retail strip in April and now somebody is pitching me a 22-key budget hotel outside Flagstaff as the next move
What flag did you have to look up? That matters a lot because some of the smaller budget brands have PIP requirements baked into the franchise agreement that trigger the second own…
Reply · 9 points
Can you actually bid at a Richmond City trustee sale with a contractor's license on file but no prior auction history
60k liquid at a Richmond city sale is tight if you hit a competitive lot.
Reply · 12 points
My agent missed a $14,000 price drop that sat on MLS for 11 days before another buyer caught it
The thing that sticks with me is "he said the drop triggered a separate MLS entry," and that explanation is probably accurate, lots of MLSs do that, but a working agent already kno…
Reply · 12 points
Does a mezz position need its own appraisal or can I rely on what the senior already ordered
Cincinnati retail cap rates moved about 75 bps in that window, which on a $4.05M value is not nothing.
Reply · 4 points
Does a tenant-buyer's default on the lease void the option or do those two documents survive independently
Drafted mine as a single combined document once and the attorney I used in Stark County told me to stop doing that immediately. His point was that a merged "lease-option agreement"…
Reply · 11 points
The repurchase suspension clause in most private REIT PPMs can be triggered without a default, and the threshold is lower than most investors read it to be.
Sold out of a non-traded REIT position in 2019, took about fourteen months to get fully out and that was before any suspension, just ordinary gate throttling. So I have some feel f…
Reply · 17 points