Second liens on crowdfunded deals keep catching people off guard when the capital stack unravels
A deal worth studying: a sponsor raises 400k through a crowdfunding platform as a second lien at 11 percent on a light industrial conversion. The senior note is 1.8 million. The property appraises at 2.6 million at origination. That feels like room. Then the market softens, a buyer falls out, and the asset trades at a distressed price of 1.9 million. The senior lender takes their 1.8 million plus fees and default interest. What reaches the second lien position is somewhere between thin and nothing, depending on how those costs stack. The 11 percent coupon that made the deal attractive was the return for absorbing that exact risk, but the marketing page showed the LTV at origination, not the recovery math if things go sideways. The number that tends to surprise people is not the loss itself but how small the gap has to be between distressed sale price and senior balance before a second lien goes to zero. On the deal above, the property only had to sell at 7 percent below appraisal for the junior position to be fully wiped. What I want to know from people allocating across multiple platforms is whether they track second lien exposure as its own line in their crowdfunding sleeve, or whether position count and advertised rate are still doing most of the work in how they build the book.