I'm nine months out from a first farm and can't think straight about lease type

Question

I'm probably nine months from closing on my first piece, somewhere between 80 and 120 tillable acres. Two neighbors have already told me two different things about how to lease it out.

Cash rent means the operator pays me a fixed dollar amount per acre for the year, and whatever happens to the crop is his problem and his upside. Crop share means we split the harvest by some agreed percentage, and usually the input costs too, so I take part of the weather and part of the price swing.

Cash rent is the version I understand. I get a number, I plan around it, and my income return sits in that modest 2 to 5 percent band people here keep quoting. Crop share sounds like it pays more in a good year and pays me almost nothing in a bad one, and I'd have to actually track grain prices and input bills instead of depositing a check.

The argument for share that I can follow: in a year when commodity prices firm up and input costs ease, the cash rent tenant keeps all of that and I keep the same number I agreed to in February. Net farm income moved a lot this past cycle and none of that would have reached me.

The argument against, and this is my worry, is that I'd be taking farming risk without knowing anything about farming.

tylerbrooks9 · Answer

You've got it right on the mechanics. The part that decides it for most first time owners isn't the risk split, it's whether you'll do the work.

Crop share means you're reading settlement sheets, checking yield monitor data, agreeing on fertilizer bills, and having a conversation every time something goes wrong in the field. Some landowners enjoy that. If you want the check to arrive and the rest to be someone else's day, cash rent is the arrangement built for you, and there's nothing lazy about picking it.

There's a middle option nobody mentioned to you. Flexible cash rent sets a base per acre and adds a bonus when yield or price clears a trigger you both agree on in the lease. You keep a floor, you catch some of the good years, and you never touch an input invoice. Ask any operator you interview whether they'll write one, because plenty will and plenty won't.

One practical thing: whatever you pick, get the lease in writing with the termination notice date spelled out. Notice requirements for ending a farm lease are set by state law and the dates are unforgiving, so have someone licensed in your state look at the document before you sign the first one.

I'm nine months out from a first farm and can't think straight about lease type

1 reply