Four rooms filled in a house where the whole-unit comp was $2,400, and the per-room total landed at $3,100.
The property was a four-bedroom in a mid-tier market, listed as a single-family rental with a whole-house asking rent that looked reasonable against the comp set. The acquisition math at that rent was unremarkable, a cap rate that would not excite anyone. The decision to run it as individual rooms came from one number: the average asking rent for a furnished room within a half-mile was $775, against a whole-house rent of $2,400 split four ways, which is $600 a room. That $175 spread per room, times four, times twelve, is $8,400 a year on the same debt service and the same tax bill.
What the pro forma missed, and what actually cost money, was turnover friction. Two of the four rooms turned in the first year, one after six months and one after nine. Each turn ran about $400 in cleaning, minor repairs and re-listing time. So the real first-year gain over a whole-house lease was closer to $7,600 than $8,400, and that assumes the rooms re-leased within three weeks, which they did, but which is not a law.
The assumption doing the most work in a per-room projection is not the rent, it is the days-vacant rate between tenancies. At $775 a room, one room sitting empty for 30 days costs $775. At a whole-house rent of $2,400, one month vacant costs $2,400, but the exposure is binary: either the house is full or it is completely empty. Per-room vacancy is smoother and smaller in each instance, but it compounds because the events are more frequent.
The management fee question matters here too. A property manager who will handle individual room leases typically charges more than one running a whole-house tenancy, sometimes 12 to 15 percent of collected room revenue against 8 to 10 percent for a single lease. Price that in before the acquisition, because it closes about a third of the per-room premium in markets where management is competitive.
What market are you running rooms in, and are you self-managing or have you found a manager willing to handle per-room leases at a rate that still leaves the spread intact?