This is what a redemption gate actually looks like when it hits a fund position

Question

Take an LP two years into a $50k allocation in an open-ended private debt fund. The redemption notice says quarterly repurchases are limited to 5 percent of NAV and this quarter's requests exceeded that, prorated. About $2,400 comes back on the $50k position, and that is normal under the fund's terms. The fund in this example: a first-time manager running bridge debt, 12 loans at around $28M of NAV. Coupons 10.5 to 12, mostly 18 month terms on light value-add multifamily, 70 to 75 LTC. Fees 1.5 on invested plus 20 over an 8 pref. The part worth reading closely before subscribing is the valuation policy. If loans are carried at par unless a borrower misses a payment, and borrowers start hitting maturity with no refinance available around month 14, a manager extending those loans often moves the accrual to PIK, meaning interest capitalizes into the loan balance instead of arriving as cash. On paper the fund can still show a 10 percent yield. In an LP's account, the distribution drops from 9 percent annualized to 4, then to 2, because the cash isn't showing up. So the mark says par, the pref accrues, and capital sits behind a queue of other LPs. None of that needs to involve fraud. It's a maturity mismatch that was in the documents from the start. Worth asking for the loan tape by maturity date, asking who marks the loans and whether that party is independent, and asking what happens to distributions when an extension is granted. The coupon was never the real question.

Rena Guide · Accepted Answer

Licensing is triggered by the activity, and the activity that triggers it in most states is negotiating, listing, showing, or bringing parties together for compensation. Sitting with someone and analyzing numbers on a property he found himself is generally further from that line than acting as his agent. Generally is doing real work in that sentence. The definitions differ state by state, some states sweep in anyone who advises on value for a fee, and a few have separate appraisal rules that bite the moment you put a number on what a property is worth. Your state's real estate commission publishes the statutory definition of brokerage activity, and reading it takes an hour. If it's close, ask a lawyer licensed in your state.

On the pricing data, roughly a dozen states are non-disclosure states, meaning sale prices are never recorded publicly. In those places everyone works from what the co-op and the closing attorneys and the local bank know, so you're not doing something unusual. What you owe a paying client is honesty about the source. Say "three people told me it went for around 140 and I couldn't verify it" rather than presenting it as recorded.

One thing to sort out before you take the couple hundred. If he buys it and it goes badly, what did he think he was paying for? Write two sentences describing what you'll deliver and what you're not doing, send it by email, and have him reply yes. That's a scope, and it's the whole difference between a consultation and a misunderstanding.

This is what a redemption gate actually looks like when it hits a fund position

1 reply