Mixed rental term lengths on the same portfolio create a management problem most fee structures never account for
A case worth studying: a 12-unit portfolio, eight units on annual leases and four listed on a short-term platform, all owned by one person, all under one management agreement at nine percent of collected rent. The annual side collects predictably and needs maybe two hours of active management per unit per month. The short-term side collects at two to three times the monthly rate but runs closer to twelve hours per unit on a busy month, counting turnovers, platform messaging, dynamic pricing checks, linen coordination and damage claims. The agreement charges the same nine percent on both. The manager is subsidizing the short-term units with margin earned on the annual ones, and the owner has no idea that is the arrangement because the fee sheet never said otherwise. The number that exposes the problem is not the revenue line, it is labor hours per collected dollar. On the annual units that number is comfortable. On the short-term units it is close to break-even before anything goes wrong. A single damage dispute or a platform hold on a payout turns it negative. The structure that actually fits a mixed portfolio separates the two fee schedules entirely, charges a flat monthly per door on annual tenancies and a higher percentage, something closer to twenty to twenty-five percent, on short-term nights, with a scope-of-service addendum that lists exactly what that covers. The question that changes everything before you sign is whether the management agreement defines "rental income" to include gross short-term revenue or net after platform fees, because a nine percent fee on gross Airbnb revenue and a nine percent fee on what lands in the owner's account after the platform takes its cut are not the same number by a wide margin. What does your current agreement say about that definition, and does it treat the two term lengths as the same product?