Selling the SDIRA property after values ran up and what that actually means for the account
A deal worth studying: a self-directed IRA bought a small commercial condo in 2017 for 180,000 all cash, inside a Roth. By 2024 a broker's opinion put it at 310,000. The IRA sells, the 130,000 gain flows back into the Roth account, and because it was a Roth purchase the gain is sheltered. That part works exactly as advertised. What the account holder did not think through was what happens next, because 310,000 in cash sitting in a Roth SDIRA earns nothing until it finds a new asset, and custodian fees on cash accounts do not stop. The gap between sale and next close cost roughly eight months of dead cash and two annual maintenance fees on a diminished asset base. The redeployment plan was not ready when the sale closed, and the tax shelter that made the hold so attractive could not compensate for the drag of that idle period. A stock-and-bond Roth would have been reinvested the same afternoon. That is the structural difference nobody maps out before they sell. The other thing worth flagging: if this had been a traditional SDIRA rather than a Roth, the sale forces a valuation event and may push the account holder toward a required minimum distribution calculation in a year when the account is suddenly cash-heavy at a high number. That sequencing problem is solvable, but only if you model it before the listing goes live. What is the account structure on the property you are thinking of selling, Roth or traditional, and do you have the next asset identified?