Explaining to a beginner why a tax lien purchase isn't a house purchase

Question

A common misconception when someone first hears about tax sales is that liens sell for the amount of back taxes owed, which is true, and that this makes them a cheap way to buy a house, which is not true, and the gap between those two facts is worth explaining carefully. One approach leads with redemption. Most liens get paid off by the owner catching up on taxes, so what is actually being purchased is an interest payment, not a house. The house was never on offer in the typical case. This lands well conceptually but people tend to hear it as a technicality and mentally file it under exceptions rather than the rule. The other approach leads with the cost of the exception, the case where a lien doesn't redeem. Getting from a certificate to a deed that can be sold involves a waiting period, a foreclosure process with real filing and mailing costs, and often an occupant to deal with. A small lien purchase can become a five figure, multi year project, and the procedures differ meaningfully state to state, so anyone pursuing this needs someone local who knows their specific state's process. Both framings have a place. Redemption first sets realistic expectations for the common case, and the cost of the exception matters most for anyone who insists they're only interested in the properties that don't redeem.

laurenkim53 · Answer

In rural, low price point markets the redemption explanation rarely lands, because the parcels that fail to redeem there are often genuinely abandoned and the owner is not coming back. What gets through is the cost side. Take a parcel that could be had for $1,900 in taxes, then add the mowing orders, the missing septic, and two years of waiting before anything resolves. The arithmetic does the arguing better than the redemption statistics do.

mikeoconnell7 · Answer

The cleanest way to explain a tax sale to someone who's never looked closely tends to be neither redemption statistics nor lien mechanics on their own. Asking what they'd do the morning after they win the lien usually does more work, because most can't answer past the first step. Once they hear themselves not answering, the redemption numbers land on their own, because by then they've stopped wanting the house.

Explaining to a beginner why a tax lien purchase isn't a house purchase

2 replies