The investor closed on a lead ninety days after delivery and the bird dog agreement had a thirty-day window, so the fee is probably gone on paper.
What makes this worth studying is the assumption most agreements leave unexamined: the window starts at delivery, so it treats investor speed as outside the bird dog's risk when it is not. Escrow on a distressed single-family in most markets runs forty-five to sixty days even after a clean accepted offer, and if the investor took two weeks to make an offer, a thirty-day contract window never covered the realistic close timeline to begin with. The number doing the most work in any bird dog agreement is not the fee, it is the trigger. Delivery-to-close windows almost always lose because they measure the wrong thing. A cleaner trigger is offer acceptance, not delivery, because that is the moment the investor's own decision-making is behind you and the timeline shifts to escrow mechanics neither party controls. Take a simple round-number illustration: lead delivered day one, investor makes an offer on day eighteen, accepted day twenty, escrow closes day sixty-three. A thirty-day delivery window pays nothing. A thirty-day window from accepted offer pays on day fifty. Same deal, same work, opposite outcome, entirely because of where the clock starts. The second thing most agreements skip is an escrow-fall-through clause, because if the investor's buyer cancels and they re-open with the same seller six weeks later, the bird dog has no named right to that second close. So the question I would put to the room is this: do your agreements define the trigger as delivery, as first contact, or as accepted offer, and did you arrive at that language deliberately or did you take what someone handed you?