My Memphis BRRRR closed fine but the Columbus fourplex I already own is making me question the whole model
I know the standard argument: recycle the capital, repeat, scale. And for a long time I believed it completely. But I look at the Columbus fourplex and something bugs me. I bought it conventionally, put cash in, never pulled it out. By BRRRR logic that is dead capital sitting there. But the thing throws off about $1,340 a month net, the tenants barely call me, and two of them have been there since 2021. I have done exactly nothing active with it in 18 months.
The Memphis BRRRR was textbook. Bought at $89k, put $31k into it, refinanced at $148k appraised, pulled back roughly $22k of my $31k. So I recycled capital, great, the model worked. But I have been managing that relationship with the contractor, the lender, the property manager, the appraiser. Columbus I genuinely forget about until the rent hits.
The part I cannot figure out is whether the recycled $22k actually did more work than the $31k stuck in Columbus. I have not deployed that $22k into a third deal yet, so right now it is just sitting in a money market at 4.9 percent and doing nothing the BRRRR model promised it would do. The whole engine depends on the repeat. If you stall between deals, the recycled capital advantage disappears pretty fast.
Phoenix is still sitting there as a question mark for me. If anyone has run BRRRR numbers in the East Valley in the last 12 months I want to know what the appraisals actually came in at relative to ARV estimates, because everything I projected going in was off by more than I expected.