My insurance housing experiment in Little Rock cleared $4,200 a month on a four-bed and I would do it again with one change
Got into insurance housing almost by accident. A restoration contractor I lent money to on a flip called me in January 2023 asking if I knew anyone with a furnished four-bed in Little Rock because his adjuster contact had a family displaced by a kitchen fire and nowhere to put them. I did not have a property there but I knew someone who did, connected them, watched the whole thing from the sideline, and decided I wanted to be on the other side of that call.
The unit I eventually furnished in Little Rock was a four-bed, two-bath in the Hillcrest area. I put $22,000 into furniture and housewares, not counting the unit itself. Gross on the insurance placement ran $4,200 a month for the first stay, which was 74 days. The adjuster paid on a net-30 invoice, no drama. Second placement came in 19 days after the first family left. Third placement had a 41-day gap and that one hurt because the fixed costs don't pause.
What I tried alongside it: one mid-term on Furnished Finder that ran 90 days at $3,100, and a direct corporate lease with a medical staffing company at $3,400 for six months. The staffing lease was the most predictable of the three. Showed up on the first every month, no calls about the coffee maker, and when the six months ended they renewed for three more. Insurance housing paid the most per night but the gap between placements is real and the adjuster timelines vary. I had one invoice that sat 47 days before it cleared and I had to chase it twice.
The one change I would make: I underpriced the gap risk. I modeled 85 percent occupancy and hit closer to 71 percent in year one once I averaged across all three channels. At 71 percent on insurance rates the net was still better than a straight unfurnished long-term would have been on that unit, but not by the margin I expected. The $22,000 in furniture took about 14 months to recover after I account for what I spent replacing a couch and a mattress set that came back damaged from the first insurance family. Adjuster covered neither because I had not written it into the placement agreement clearly enough.
Corporate lease is the anchor, insurance housing is the upside, mid-term fills the holes. That is how I run it now.