New, used, or rented: how would you put furniture in a first corporate unit?

Question

I'm looking at a small house near a business corridor and the furnishing decision is the part I keep going back and forth on. Three ways I've seen described here and elsewhere, and each one has a real argument.

Buy new from one retailer as a package. You get matching pieces, one delivery date, warranty coverage, and photos that look like the listing corporate clients expect. Highest cash out, call it $12k to $16k for a three-bedroom depending on the market. The money is gone and it's in an asset that loses value fast.

Buy used and from liquidation lots. Estate sales, office liquidations, hotel FF&E auctions. People here have furnished for a third of new. It takes weeks of hunting, the pieces don't match, and if a sofa fails there's no replacing it with the same thing. Also the corporate buyer's inspection standard is not the same as a private tenant's.

Rent a furniture package monthly. Providers will deliver a whole apartment for a few hundred a month, swap damaged pieces, and pick it all up when the lease ends. No capital out, no storage, no depreciation. It comes straight off the spread every month you're occupied, and off it every month you're vacant too, unless you terminate and lose the ability to show the unit furnished.

What argues against the way I lean is that the rental option converts a capital problem into an operating cost, and if the annual furnished occupancy turns out to be four months instead of eight, that's the option that doesn't hurt. The case for buying is that at eight months occupied the rental fee eats the premium you went furnished for.

What would you actually do on unit one, before you know your occupancy?

priya_n21 · Answer

I'd rent it on unit one and I'd expect to be talked out of that here.

My reasoning is that the thing you don't know on unit one is whether the corporate demand is real in your specific corridor. Renting costs you maybe $350 a month of spread and buys you an exit that doesn't involve selling a sectional on marketplace for $180. If the first two placements go well, you buy on the third and you're out a few hundred a month for the education.

Where I'm less sure is the swap-out service. If a provider will replace a damaged piece within a week, that's worth something real on a corporate placement where you can't have a broken bed while someone's living there. If they take three weeks like everyone else, then I'm paying rent for a service I'm not getting and I'd rather own and keep a spare.

New, used, or rented: how would you put furniture in a first corporate unit?

1 reply