Did a pre-foreclosure deal in Stockton last spring and I want to show the numbers so people can tell me where I left money on the table
Borrower was 73 days past due, no NOD filed yet, so I had a window. Got to them through a skip trace off a delinquency list I bought for $400 covering San Joaquin County. Called twice, no answer, sent a letter, got a call back four days later. They owed $218k on a property that comped around $310k in decent condition. Interior showed deferred maintenance, one bathroom gutted, roof maybe five years left. I offered $241k, which covered their payoff and gave them $23k to move. They countered at $255k and we settled at $249,500. Repair budget I put together without walking the gutted bathroom came in at $38k. Actual cost was $54,200, most of that in a subfloor situation I could not have seen without demo. After carrying costs of $9,100 for the four months it took to sell, I cleared $28,400 net on a $312,800 sale. That is not a bad deal but it is not the deal I modeled either. What I underpriced was the interior-unknown risk on a property I visited once and that one visit was with the borrower present, which changes what you actually see. The borrower was motivated but not desperate, and that distinction cost me about half my projected margin at the negotiating stage. I would have offered $238k if I had priced the inspection risk correctly from the start.