Subject-to I funded went sideways in Cook County and I want to document what actually happened
The borrower stopped making payments in March of last year, eleven months into a deal where my fund held a second behind a 214,000 dollar first. The acquiring investor had taken title subject-to, so the first stayed in the original borrower's name throughout. When the acquiring investor stopped performing, the original borrower's credit started taking the hits and that person called me before anyone else because my number was on the original paperwork. Illinois is a judicial foreclosure state, which meant the lender filed in circuit court and the clock stretched out longer than I had modeled. From filing to sheriff's sale ran about fourteen months in Cook County, though I have heard of longer. The original borrower had no standing to cure because they had already deeded the property, and the acquiring investor had no real motivation to cure because they were underwater on the rehab. My second was at 41,000 dollars and I watched it get wiped when the first sold at sheriff's sale for 231,000, which covered the first and costs and nothing else. The legal exposure I had not fully thought through before writing the check was the due-on-sale clause. The original lender could have accelerated the moment the deed transferred. They did not, but they had the right to, and in a default scenario they could have made the whole judicial process more complicated and more expensive. I count that as a structural error in my underwriting, not a bad outcome I could not have seen.