If the foreclosure pipeline is rising but the good inventory never reaches the public, where is it actually found?

Question

Something about how this strategy gets discussed does not add up. Filings are up and repossessions are up sharply, and everyone quotes the numbers. Yet the practical experience of anyone trying to buy is that the auction is crowded and the REO listings clear at retail. The explanation offered is that distress resolves before auction, through modifications and workouts or through investors buying early. Fine, but the phrase investors buying early is doing an enormous amount of work and nobody breaks it down. Who is buying early, and at what stage and through what channel? If a meaningful share of defaults are intercepted before the auction, the auction and REO channels are structurally the leftovers, and every beginner being pointed at those channels is being pointed at the picked over end of the pipeline. The same dynamic is well documented in tax delinquent land, where institutional buyers work the list eighteen months before the sale and what reaches the public auction is what they rejected. Is the residential foreclosure pipeline the same shape, and if so what does an individual operator actually do about it?

Rena Expert · Accepted Answer

The residential pipeline isn't captured by institutions the way tax-delinquent land often is, and the reason is that residential default resolution is dominated by the servicer, not by a buyer. Most defaults that don't reach auction don't get bought early at all. They get cured, modified, forborne, refinanced, or listed by the homeowner as a normal retail sale with enough equity to pay off the note. In an environment where owners have accumulated equity, the ordinary MLS sale is the single largest exit for a distressed homeowner, and no investor touches it. So "resolves before auction" mostly means the debt gets fixed or the house gets sold at market, not that a smarter investor got there first.

What that changes about your conclusion: the auction and REO channels aren't the rejects of a private buying scrum. They're the residue of files where nothing else worked, usually because there's no equity, the title is a mess, the property is uninhabitable, or the owner has disappeared. That's a different kind of leftover. The problem with the survivors is condition and legal complexity rather than someone else having skimmed the value.

Which points at where the individual edge actually sits. If the reason a file reached auction is that it's ugly in a specific way, then whoever can price that specific ugliness buys it below the crowd. Estate and probate situations with unclear heirs, houses with unpermitted additions, occupied properties where the eviction is a state-by-state question, structural work that scares generalist flippers. Those don't get bid to retail because the bidder pool that can underwrite them is small.

And pike is right that the pre-foreclosure list is crowded rather than owned. Eleven identical letters means the marginal letter is worth almost nothing, and the operator who shows up in person, or who works a narrower list harder, isn't fighting the same eleven people. The competition is thick at the top of the funnel and thin at the parts that require judgment.

jordan_ellis2 · Answer

Six months of pulling lists and I'd say yes, the shape is the same. The notice of default list in my county gets scraped the day it records and by the time I get a mail piece out those homeowners have had eleven letters. But there's a difference from your tax land situation. Those eleven letters are mostly from small operators sending the same template, not from institutions. Nobody's buying the whole list wholesale. It's crowded, not captured.

gregpowell66 · Answer

The condition point is the one to underline. Take an auction file where the photos show a sagging ridge line and the bidding comes in $40k lighter than comparable boxes on the same street. Most of that gap is fear, and perhaps $18k of it is actual work. The catch is that you have to tell those apart from a drive-by, and that takes years of looking at roofs.

carlos_nunez · Answer

Yes and no, @gregpowell66. The trap is assuming the visible thing is the whole thing. A sagging ridge can also mean the exterior wall has moved, which means foundation, which is a completely different number. The discount at auction on ugly houses isn't always mispricing. Sometimes the crowd is right and one person in the crowd is wrong.

megan_doyle15 · Answer

Genuinely didn't know most defaults just get cured or sold normally. I had a picture in my head of a funnel that all ends at the courthouse steps.

devon_pierce · Answer

One practical change that follows from this thread is to stop pulling the whole county NOD file. Pull one zip, which in most counties runs about 30 to 40 records a month, and hit those forty six ways rather than four thousand once. The honest question with that approach is whether it is a real strategy or a rationalization for having no marketing budget, and the answer depends entirely on whether the six touches actually go out.

raj_mehta14 · Answer

Where do the notes fit in this though? If a servicer cannot cure a file and does not want to carry it to auction, some of those loans get sold as non-performing paper before the foreclosure completes. That looks like a fourth entry point that is missing from the three stage picture, and it is the one that gets written about most and explained least.

nataliehsu · Answer

@rajmehta14 I've wondered the same. From what I can tell the note pools are mostly sold in tranches with minimums well past what an individual brings, so it's a real channel but not the same room as this one. @nicoleadeyemi your original framing stuck with me though, because the answer that came back is basically that the edge is specialist knowledge about damaged property, and that's a trade skill more than a finance skill. Which is either encouraging or discouraging depending on what you already know.

If the foreclosure pipeline is rising but the good inventory never reaches the public, where is it actually found?

8 replies