A paid scope walk is the reason a refresh can land near budget

Take a 1,100 sf three bed in a tired but stable suburb, rented at 1,650, where a rehab finishes at 39,400 against a 38,000 budget. Most guidance says to expect 20 percent over, so landing at 3.7 percent over is a result worth studying. The difference maker: paying a contractor a flat fee, say 400, to walk the house and write the scope himself, room by room, before anyone bids it, with the understanding that he isn't bidding the job. Forty one lines, written plainly. Three crews then bid the same 41 lines, which makes the bids genuinely comparable because they're pricing identical words. A typical breakdown might land like this: kitchen cabinets and counters 14,200, two baths 9,100, LVP through the whole floor 5,600, paint inside 3,400, panel swap plus odds and ends 4,900, rot under the back threshold found in week two 2,200. What nearly breaks a budget like this is lead time. Cabinet lead time stretching from three weeks to seven after ordering is a common failure point, especially when the crew has another job lined up and would otherwise be lost for a month. Resequencing, doing both baths and the flooring first, and swapping to an in-stock door style are typical workarounds. Six and a half weeks instead of five is a reasonable outcome for that kind of hiccup. Worth keeping in any rehab: the paid scope walk, and the rule that no change happens until there's a dollar figure in writing and an explicit yes. A single, clearly scoped change order for the discovered rot is the sign of a process that's working.

tylerbrooks9 AO1APRO 10

Answer

raj_mehta14 PF4BPRO 10

A scope walk fee tends to buy two things and only one of them is the comparison shopping. The other is that itemized lines with numbers attached mean everyone already agrees on what the original job was when something unexpected shows up. That's the whole fight in most of these threads. People argue about whether something was in scope, and there's no document that settles it. A written scope does. The part worth borrowing is the dollar figure before work starts rule. In subcontracts this shows up as a written change order clause, sometimes with a line saying verbal changes don't bind anybody. A text message version is the small scale of the same idea. Worth checking is whether the allowance lines named actual products. If a scope says cabinets 14,200 and nothing else, the crew's $14,200 cabinet and the buyer's $14,200 cabinet are different objects, and that gets discovered at delivery. If a line and door style were named, then a swap to in-stock is a measurable downgrade that can be priced and refunded.

raj_mehta14 PF4BPRO 10

7 replies

carlos_nunez AA4APRO 12

The resequence is doing more work here than the scope document. If those baths had not been ready to start, meaning a plumbing rough or an inspection sitting in front of them, the crew leaves and this is a post about losing seven weeks. Was it known that the baths could go first when the cabinets were ordered, or did that just happen to be true?

carlos_nunez AA4APRO 12

devon_pierce SS4APRO 15

How did the contractor who wrote the scope get found, and did he mind that his words were going to get shopped to two competitors? Building a list of crews takes time, and it's still not obvious how to make that first ask without sounding like it's wasting somebody's morning.

devon_pierce SS4APRO 15

nicole_adeyemi SS3APRO 13

The panel swap is the line worth watching on any refresh like this one. Permit and inspection timing on electrical work varies a lot by jurisdiction, and in some counties the inspector's calendar is the schedule whatever the crew says. Ask the AHJ before building the sequence around it.

nicole_adeyemi SS3APRO 13

bmoreno23ActivePRO

Coming from zero here, what does allowance actually mean in this context? I've seen it three times today and I've been assuming it's just a budget line, but vellum is talking about it like it's a specific thing in the contract.

bmoreno23ActivePRO

luis_carrera CS1CPRO 12

A rehab spreadsheet with a single cell called rehab is the common starting point, and a post like this is a small insult to that spreadsheet, in a useful way. The alternative is 41 lines somebody who owns tools wrote. Paying $400 to convert one cell into 41 is a better trade than most line items an operator will run all year.

luis_carrera CS1CPRO 12

brandonlee36 SP1BPRO 15

The reuse is where this pays off twice. Nine doors into a rental portfolio, a scope doc for a two bed turn tends to become the same document every time with the numbers updated, and it usually takes about four properties before it stops growing. Quarry is right that the resequence saved the project, but the reason a crew is willing to resequence at all is that they can see exactly what work is left and that they'll get paid for it. Vague scope means the crew hedges by going where the certain money is.

brandonlee36 SP1BPRO 15

Reply Anonymous