Does a small motel need a different insurance policy from a fourplex, and what actually changes?

Question

This comes up when a small multifamily owner looks at a first motel. Say an owner has two fourplexes on landlord policies with the same agent, and a 19 room motel two towns over comes up at a price that does not seem crazy. The agent says she cannot write it and would need to send it to a commercial lines person because hotels are a different animal. On the surface that is hard to understand. It is a building with rooms in it and people sleeping in them, same as a fourplex, except the people leave sooner. The meetup version of the answer is that the big difference is liquor liability and that an owner who does not serve alcohol is basically fine. That does not sound complete. What actually changes on the insurance side, and roughly what should an owner expect it to cost compared to a residential policy?

Rena Guide · Accepted Answer

Your agent is right that it's a different line of business. A landlord policy assumes tenants under leases occupying units for months. A hotel is an operating business with the public coming and going nightly, employees on site, and no lease shifting any responsibility to the occupant. That changes the underwriting category, and most personal-lines or small-landlord agents aren't licensed or appointed to place it.

What's typically in a lodging program that isn't in your fourplex policy: commercial general liability at limits well above residential, business income coverage that pays when rooms can't be sold rather than when rent stops, workers compensation once you have any employees, employment practices liability, and crime or employee dishonesty coverage because staff handle cash and guest property. Innkeeper's liability covers guest belongings, which has no residential equivalent. If you have a pool, shuttle van, or restaurant, each adds its own exposure and its own carrier appetite question. Liquor liability only matters if alcohol is served, so the meetup answer was one true detail out of a longer list.

On cost, lodging property and liability generally runs several times a residential per-unit figure, and it varies enormously by state, by construction type, by whether you have a pool, and by loss history, so any number I give you would mislead. Get two or three quotes from brokers who write hospitality specifically.

The piece people skip: your lender and, if the motel is flagged, the franchisor will both dictate minimum limits and required endorsements. Read those requirements before you shop, because a policy that satisfies your comfort level and fails the brand standard means buying it twice.

mitchell_ray4 · Answer

Liquor is one line item, not the reason. I've done service work in a couple of small motels and the thing that jumps out is the pool. Pool, hot tub, or spa on site changes the general liability conversation more than anything else, and a lot of carriers just won't write a lodging property with an unfenced or unattended one. Also your fourplex tenants sign a lease and take on some responsibility for their own space. A guest doesn't, so slip and fall on the parking lot at 2am is entirely yours.

ehernandez74 · Answer

The employee side is what stops most fourplex owners who look at a place this size. Two fourplexes need a handyman on call. A 19 room motel needs someone at the desk or at least reachable, plus housekeeping every morning and a laundry running daily. Workers comp rates on hotel housekeeping classifications are not trivial, and the owner is now an employer with payroll filings. That is a job rather than a policy question, but it tends to arrive through the same conversation you are having with your agent.

Does a small motel need a different insurance policy from a fourplex, and what actually changes?

3 replies