Does a finished lot sale at $118k to a national builder pencil the same as $118k to a regional builder
I have one 12-lot infill project under LOI in Huntsville and both a national and a regional builder have toured it, both verbally floated $118k per lot, but the national wants a 24-month takedown spread across four equal closings and the regional wants all 12 at once in month nine. The national's schedule pushes my total carry to roughly $190k at my current hard money rate, while the regional closing in month nine keeps carry around $70k, so the gross revenue looks identical on paper but the regional deal actually nets me close to $120k more after carry. The regional builder is smaller and I keep wondering whether a simultaneous 12-lot closing is more execution risk than a staggered schedule with a creditworthy national, especially since my out-of-state rental taught me that things go sideways when I'm not watching closely.