Does squeezing a contractor's bid actually save money on a flip or just move the problem
Working on my spec build right now, so this is sitting on my desk in a pretty literal way. The lot was cash, $41k in Cleveland Heights, and I am getting bids for the full build that are coming in between $190k and $230k on the same scope. Everyone in this space will tell you to push back on the high bids, get three quotes, negotiate hard. That is the standard move and I believed it for a long time.
What I am running into is that the two contractors who came in lowest both hedged somewhere in the conversation. One said he could "work with me on allowances." The other one has a crew of two and a list of four active jobs. Those are not bids I want to squeeze further. The guy at $218k has pulled permits in this zip code six times in the last two years and his sub for electrical is someone I have actually verified. I am not negotiating with him. I am trying not to lose him.
The place I have actually saved money on contractor costs is scope, not price. On my duplex in Elk Grove I cut about $9,000 by pulling the full bathroom gut out of the contract and doing a cosmetic refresh instead. The contractor price per unit of work stayed the same. I just bought less work. That math holds. Telling a contractor his labor rate is too high and waiting to see if he bites usually just tells me he is hungry for a reason.
The flip margin I am building toward on this spec is around $55k if everything prices where I modeled it. A contractor who cuts his number under pressure and then slow-walks the job, or disappears at rough-in, costs me $4,500 a month in carry alone. That math is not close.