Pricing a second lien NPN when the first is current but underwater
A defaulted second behind a performing first is a genuinely different animal from a first lien workout, and I think the pricing logic gets collapsed in a way that costs buyers on both ends. Take a property with a $210,000 first that is current and a $45,000 second that has been non-performing for 14 months. The ARV comes in at $230,000. That $20,000 of equity above the first sounds like something, but it is not what you are actually buying. You are buying the probability that the first stays current through your resolution timeline, that the borrower has enough motivation to cure or negotiate, and that you can exit before carrying costs and servicer fees consume the spread. If the first goes delinquent while you are working the second, your collateral position does not change on paper but your practical recovery compresses fast. The bid on that second has to price the first's performance risk as a live variable, and most tapes I see treat it as a given. The other assumption doing real work here is the workout timeline. A loan mod on a second behind a current first can move faster than a first lien foreclosure, but only if the borrower has income to document and the servicer can actually execute a modification on a subordinate lien, which not all of them will touch. A deed in lieu on the second is cleaner operationally but requires the first lien holder's cooperation on title, and that cooperation is not guaranteed. Cash for keys lands somewhere in between on cost and speed but you are also forfeiting any deficiency angle, which on a $45,000 UPB is not trivial if the borrower has attachable assets. The exit you price at acquisition almost never matches the one the borrower hands you, but on a second the gap between modeled exit and actual exit tends to be wider because you have one more party whose behavior you cannot control. What does your servicer quote for a modification on a subordinate lien, and does that number change once you tell them the first is with a different servicer?