Old gas station under the lot, seller has an NFA letter from the 90s, lender still wants a Phase II

Question

45-space corner surface lot, asking $1.1M, trailing NOI around $78,000, so about 7.1% on the income alone. The site was a branded gas station until 1987. Tanks were pulled, and the seller has a no further action letter from the state environmental agency dated 1998.

My Phase I came back with the historical use flagged as a recognized environmental condition anyway. Phase II quotes are running $18,000 to $25,000 depending on how many borings and whether they add soil gas. The lender says the NFA letter doesn't satisfy them.

Here's my actual problem. I'm not buying this for 7.1%. I'm buying it because the block is filling in and in ten or fifteen years the land is worth more than the parking. If the soil work says the site is fine to keep as asphalt but expensive to build vertical on, I've paid a land-banking price for an income asset. How do people underwrite that gap before they've spent $25k finding out?

Rena Expert · Accepted Answer

Anchor named it. Most state programs close sites to a use-based standard, and a 1998 commercial or non-residential closure often carries a land use restriction recorded against the deed. Pull the deed and the state's site file and see whether there's an environmental covenant limiting use, excavation, or groundwater. How that restriction binds a future owner is a state law question, so get an environmental attorney licensed there to read it rather than relying on the consultant's summary.

On the underwriting gap: split the price. At $78k NOI, an 8% going-in cap on parking income supports roughly $975k. You're paying $1.1M, so about $125,000 of the price is the land option, which is cheap if the block really is filling in. Now put a number on the downside. A vapor mitigation system under a new building on a former station site is commonly a six-figure line, plus contaminated soil disposal at a per-ton rate that varies wildly by state and by how the soil classifies. If the Phase II comes back with residual impact, your $125k option premium is sitting behind a much larger future cost, and the buyer you eventually sell to will discount for it.

Structure around the unknown instead of guessing. Ask for a price reduction or an escrow holdback tied to Phase II findings, and ask your broker about a pollution legal liability policy with a term long enough to cover your hold. Coverage for known conditions is priced very differently from coverage for unknowns.

One more thing. Asphalt over impacted soil functions as a cap, and some closures assume that cap stays. If your redevelopment plan is the whole point, disturbing the cap is exactly the event the closure never contemplated, and as owner you'll be the party the state talks to.

ehernandez74 · Answer

First thing I'd ask the seller for is the closure report behind the NFA letter, not just the letter. What matters is which cleanup standard it closed to and whether any tanks or piping were left in place. Closure to a commercial or industrial standard is a different animal from closure to a residential one, and if your redevelopment thesis is apartments you may be reopening the file.

renee_dubois · Answer

Ask the lender whether a satisfactory Phase II gets you the loan or whether the historical use kills it either way. Cheaper to learn that before you spend the $25k.

laurenkim53 · Answer

None of this exists at my price points, small town lots trade at land value and nobody pays for a Phase I under $200k. But the closure standard thing applies to every old filling station corner in every town, and there are a lot of them. Filing that away.

nicole_adeyemi · Answer

Quill, check the zoning before the dirt. If the city has already dropped its minimum parking requirements downtown, two things happen at once: your future development pad gets more valuable because you can build without a podium, and your parking income gets more competitive because every other owner's surplus stalls come on the market. I've seen both effects on the same block. Also pull whether there's an overlay requiring ground floor retail, since that changes what a builder will pay you.

paulgrant17 · Answer

Slightly sideways question, but on the 45 spaces, are the monthly parkers on written contracts that survive a sale? If the income half of your price rests on people who can leave with 30 days notice, the environmental risk isn't the only soft part of the number.

Old gas station under the lot, seller has an NFA letter from the 90s, lender still wants a Phase II

6 replies