Now that the MLS can't publish it, where does the buyer agent fee live as a document?

Question

Before the rule change, as I understand it, the offer of compensation to the buyer's broker sat in the MLS listing field and the split happened more or less automatically through the two brokerages at closing. I pay more attention to the paperwork than to the houses themselves, so bear with me.

That field is gone. So what's the paper trail now? There has to be something that obligates the seller to pay, otherwise it's a handshake, and I don't believe a title company disburses money on a handshake. I've seen the phrase "concession" used and also "compensation agreement between brokers" and I don't know if those are the same thing wearing two names.

Rena Guide · Accepted Answer

They're not the same thing, and the difference matters for how the money moves.

The first document is the buyer representation agreement between you and your broker. That's the one required in writing before touring since August 17, 2024, and it states what you owe your broker. That obligation is yours regardless of what the seller does.

The second is whatever gets the seller to fund it. Two common routes. One is a seller concession written into the purchase contract or an addendum, where the seller agrees to credit a dollar amount or percentage toward your costs, and you then apply that to your broker's fee. The other is a separate compensation agreement signed between the listing broker and the buyer's broker, which sits outside the purchase contract entirely. Which form your market uses depends on the state association's forms and local practice, so ask your agent to show you the actual form they'll use.

The third document is the settlement statement at closing. Whatever route was used, the disbursement appears there with the brokerages named, and that's what the title or escrow company actually acts on. You're right that nobody wires on a handshake.

One wrinkle worth raising with your lender early rather than late. If the fee is structured as a seller concession, it may count against the limits your loan program puts on how much a seller can contribute to your side of the table. Those limits vary by loan type and the treatment of buyer-agent compensation has been actively debated, so confirm the current handling in writing with your lender before you set the number in the offer.

ehernandez74 · Answer

So if I read that right, the buyer agreement is the only one that binds me personally, and everything else is just where the funding comes from. That's clearer than anything I've read. Does the buyer agreement usually state a percentage or a dollar amount?

sonia_alvarez · Answer

The concession cap point is the one that bites. On some programs the seller contribution limit steps down hard once your down payment is small, and if your agent fee is eating that allowance you've got less room for rate buydown or prepaids. Worth a call to the lender before you write, not after.

paulgrant17 · Answer

@anchor mine was written as a percentage with a minimum dollar floor underneath it, which I nearly missed. On a cheap property the floor is what actually applies.

laurenkim53 · Answer

That floor is the whole story out here. Percentage of $95,000 at 2.5% is $2,375, and no agent is driving 40 minutes each way for that, so the agreements come with a $3,500 or $4,000 minimum. Sellers at that price point often won't cover it either, so it's cash from me.

angela_burke · Answer

One thing on the broker to broker agreement route. Because it sits outside the purchase contract, the timing of when it gets signed matters a lot. Get it signed before the offer goes in, otherwise you're relying on a listing broker to agree to a number after they already have an accepted contract in hand. I've seen agents leave that until day three of escrow and then discover the number moved.

brandonlee36 · Answer

@hollow the floor thing surprised me too when I looked at a low price point market. It effectively makes the fee regressive against cheap houses, which is exactly where a buyer has the least cash spare.

Now that the MLS can't publish it, where does the buyer agent fee live as a document?

7 replies