The non-recourse loan inside a self-directed IRA has a spread problem most people skip over before they close.
A conventional investment property might carry debt at a spread of 150 to 200 basis points over the unlevered cap rate and still make sense, because the interest is deductible. Inside an IRA, the deduction disappears, and the debt-financed portion of net income gets taxed as unrelated debt-financed income, so the effective spread the loan has to clear is wider than the nominal rate suggests. Take a property at a 7 percent cap rate carrying a non-recourse loan at 7.5 percent. Outside the IRA that spread is painful but maybe survivable with appreciation. Inside a traditional SDIRA, you are paying UDFI tax on the leveraged fraction of income and still carrying the full interest cost, which means the loan is working against you at almost any realistic cap rate in the current environment. The Roth changes the picture somewhat because qualified distributions eventually come out clean, but you still owe UDFI in the years the property is held with debt on it, so the benefit is deferred rather than eliminated. The Solo 401k sidesteps UDFI entirely on most real estate debt, which is why that comparison keeps appearing in this room. The structure question matters more than the rate by the time you model it out five years. What is the hold period you are underwriting, and is the loan fixed or does it have a balloon that forces a sale or refinance inside the account?