Who actually signs what in a self-directed IRA real estate deal: custodian, IRA, LLC, or the account holder

Question

On a direct IRA purchase, the purchase contract gets signed by the custodian as trustee for the benefit of the IRA, and the account holder signs a direction letter directing the purchase. In the checkbook LLC structure, the IRA owns an LLC, the LLC owns the property, and the account holder acts as manager. The distinction is between administrative management of the entity and operational involvement with the asset. Signing LLC paperwork or authorizing a vendor payment is treated differently than personally doing repair work, collecting rent, or otherwise taking personal benefit. Where that line sits depends on the facts and the custodian's policies, so confirm with an attorney familiar with prohibited transaction rules before the LLC is formed. The reason to add the LLC when the IRA can hold the deed directly is usually transaction speed, privacy, and sometimes liability containment, weighed against the cost of a separate entity.

Rena Guide · Accepted Answer

Two different things are being mixed together, so let me separate them.

Direct ownership: the deed reads something like "ABC Trust Company FBO Warrant IRA." The custodian signs the contract and the deed on the account's instruction. You sign a direction letter for each transaction. Rent goes to the custodian, invoices go to the custodian, and the custodian pays them. Slow, and hard to get wrong.

The LLC version: the IRA buys 100 percent of the membership interest in a new LLC, the LLC opens a bank account, and the LLC buys the house. You're often named manager so you can sign at the bank. Being manager lets you sign documents and direct money. It does not let you swing a hammer, collect rent into your own account, or use the property. The prohibited-transaction rules follow the money into the LLC, they don't stop at the custodian's door. Managing the paperwork is allowed. Providing labor or personal benefit is not, and that line is the same whether or not there's an LLC.

Why add the LLC: speed, liability separation between the property and the rest of the account, and easier joint ownership if two IRAs invest together. What you're taking on is that you become the person deciding whether each payment is compliant, with no custodian looking at it first, plus the LLC's own annual state filing fee and whatever your state charges. Some states also treat single-member LLCs differently for franchise tax, so that's a state-specific question.

Whether a manager-managed IRA LLC is appropriate for your situation is a question for a tax attorney. The structure has been litigated, and how it's documented and how you're compensated (you generally aren't) matter to the answer.

luis_carrera · Answer

The LLC version is what people call a checkbook IRA. The appeal is speed, since you're not waiting days for the custodian to cut every check. The tradeoff is that every check you write is one you're personally responsible for having written correctly, and the compliance surface gets much bigger.

joe_delgado5 · Answer

Worth adding that some non-recourse lenders won't lend to an IRA-owned LLC and some won't lend without one. Ask before you form anything, because unwinding a title vesting mid-deal is a mess.

Who actually signs what in a self-directed IRA real estate deal: custodian, IRA, LLC, or the account holder

3 replies