Who actually collects the payments on a note I carry?

Question

I'm about to carry paper for the first time on a small parcel, 68k price, 14k down, so a 54k note at 8% over 15 years with a balloon at year five. Everything I've read is about writing the note and almost nothing about the part after closing, which is somebody cashing a payment every month for the next five years.

Two ways this seems to go. I collect it myself, the buyer sends me money on the first, I keep a spreadsheet with the interest and principal split, and I save the servicing fee. That's cheap and I stay close to the loan, and if the buyer is late I hear about it the same day.

Or I pay a third party loan servicer, usually a monthly fee per loan, and they take the payment, keep the amortization schedule, produce statements, and can escrow for taxes and insurance if I set it up that way. Costs money on a small note, and I lose the direct contact.

For a note this size I honestly can't tell which is the better habit to build. Curious what people who've carried more than one would do here.

priya_n21 · Accepted Answer

I'd use a servicer, and the reason has nothing to do with the math. I wanted income without a second job, and self collecting turns a note into a small monthly job. Someone has to send the statement, chase the late payment, apply the partial payment correctly, confirm the property taxes got paid, and confirm the insurance is still in force with your name on the notices. Every one of those is a thing you'll do at 9pm because you forgot.

On a 54k note the fee is usually small next to what you're collecting, and you can often make the buyer pay it as part of the closing terms. The other reason is the record. If you ever want to sell the note or borrow against it, a servicer's payment history is what someone else can actually read and trust. My spreadsheet was worth nothing to anybody but me.

One thing to sort out before closing rather than after. Whether taxes and insurance get escrowed, and who is on the notice list, because that varies by policy and by county and it's the part that goes bad without anyone noticing. Ask your attorney how the escrow language should read for your state, since requirements differ, and put it in the documents instead of agreeing to it in an email later.

tashaford30 · Answer

The part I'd worry about is the amortization split. On a 54k note at 8% the interest portion changes every month, and if you're the one calculating it and the buyer asks for a payoff figure in year three, you're both looking at your spreadsheet and hoping it's right. A servicer generating the same statement every month means nobody argues about the balance. Whether you need one on a note this small I don't know, but I'd at least get the schedule produced by something other than a formula I typed myself.

Rena Guide · Answer

Two terms, since they get used loosely. A loan servicer is a company you hire to receive the buyer's payment, split it between interest and principal against an amortization schedule, keep the running balance, and send both sides statements. An amortization schedule is just the month by month table showing how each payment divides and what's left owing, which on your note is what produces the payoff number at the balloon.

What a servicer adds beyond convenience is a third party record. When your buyer asks for a payoff in year four, or a future note buyer asks what the payment history looks like, the answer comes from someone with no interest in the outcome. That record is also where late payments get documented, which matters if you ever have to enforce the note.

What it costs is a setup charge plus a monthly fee, and pricing varies by company, so get it in writing before you commit. On a 54k note the fee is small in absolute terms and less small as a share of your monthly collection, which is the real tradeoff parcel is describing.

One caution on escrowing taxes and insurance. Collecting and holding another party's escrow money can carry licensing or handling rules that differ by state, so confirm with your attorney how it should be set up where the property sits before you agree to hold anything yourself. Reporting the interest you receive also has its own requirements, and that's a question for your CPA.

Who actually collects the payments on a note I carry?

3 replies