Discussion
Say a property generates $2,400 a month in gross rent and you put a senior DSCR loan on it at $180,000, 7.5 percent, 30 years, which produces a payment right around $1,259. The se…
Discussion
The conflict in dual agency gets written about mostly as a pricing problem, and I think that framing misses where the real exposure sits. On a straight sale at a fixed price, the…
Discussion
A flat market strips the gap between what a seller wants and what a buyer will pay down to one negotiable surface: the note itself. Take a property priced at 280k with no bank wil…
Discussion
A seller considering a carryback has a real incentive problem. They want the value high enough to justify the price, which means the appraisal they commission before listing is wo…
Discussion
The structure most people reach for is a straight installment sale: seller holds a note, relative makes monthly payments, both sides skip the bank. That works, and the tax treatme…
Win
The sale price was $310,000, buyer put 15 percent down, I carried the balance at 7.5 percent over 20 years with a 5-year balloon. I felt good about it. Then a note buyer ran the n…
Story
I should know better than most people whether this makes sense, and I still cannot fully talk myself into it or out of it. The property is a three-bedroom in Maplewood, sitting at…
Win
A 40-year am sounds generous to the buyer because it shrinks the monthly payment, but what it actually does is keep the balance high for me at balloon time, which is the moment I…
Discussion
So I ran it after the call. My yield on this thing, once I factor in what I paid for the property, what I'll net at closing, and the term he wants, is closer to 4.1. I agreed to a…
Discussion
A case worth studying: a seller carries 70 percent on a six-unit that pencils at full occupancy, buyer has solid W-2 income, decent reserves, and the note rate is set at eight per…
Discussion
A seller financing deal structured as a land contract, sometimes called a contract for deed, hands the seller a cleaner forfeiture remedy than a mortgage foreclosure in most state…
Discussion
I have been sitting with this question on the duplex in Ohio because one of the tenants asked me, very casually, whether she could just take over the loan when I decide to sell. S…
Discussion
The note was written with a five-year balloon and an early payoff right that kicked in after twelve months. The seller priced the rate at 7.5 over an underlying at 4.25, so 3.25 p…
Discussion
A structure worth studying: a seller carries a five-year balloon at seven percent on a property they would have sold at six-cap two years ago. The buyer penciled the refi out of a…
Discussion
The property is a 3/1 in Maplewood that I've been renting out and I'm considering whether to sell it clean at around 218k or carry a note at 6.5% on maybe 160k with the buyer putt…
Win
A case to learn from, because the failure point here is one almost nobody prices in when they write the note. The property had a conventional underlying at 4.1 percent, the seller…
Discussion
A seller-carry note I reviewed recently had that phrase on page two, and the seller's attorney had marked it standard. What the next sentence said was that the lender's clock for…
Happening Now
A five year balloon felt conservative when rates were low and refinancing was easy. The assumption behind it was that the buyer would qualify for conventional financing before the…
Discussion
On land and small commercial, I ask about it on every deal where the seller is likely to be sitting on low or no basis, because the tax conversation is usually already on their mi…
Story
The property was a four bed near NC State, 2021, and I had already decided I was not going to sell it outright because the basis was low enough that a seller-financed deal made mo…
Win
Say the underlying was a 200k balance at 4.5 percent, seller wrote a wrap at 7 percent on 240k, and the spread on the 200k overlap was 2.5 points, about 415 a month before the sel…
Discussion
Take a 40-lot subdivision where the developer controls raw land at 800k. The paper lot path sells individual lots on wraps before a shovel touches the ground, say at 35k per lot w…
Happening Now
The structure comes up more often than people expect: a seller carries a note, then decides to forgive or gift the interest payments back to the buyer, either periodically or as p…
Story
Carried a note on a fourplex in Stockton, sold it in early 2022. Buyer brought 15 percent down, I carried the rest at zero interest, fully amortizing over fifteen years. I did thi…
Loss
I put in a mound system because the county flagged the original at closing and I thought buyers would pay for clean. Sold on terms six months later and the guy never mentioned it,…
Discussion
Thirty-eight thousand down on a 155k sale, so about 24 percent, and the note sits at 8.5 percent over 20 years. Monthly payment is right around $980 principal and interest, buyer…
Happening Now
The assumption I keep seeing tested is that motivated sellers carry paper because they need to move the property. Sometimes that is true, but the more durable reason in this rate…
Happening Now
My mother passed in March and left me a small rental in Clarksville, Tennessee that she was carrying paper on. Buyer has been paying since 2019, solid record, 14 payments left on…
Happening Now
Say a buyer takes a wrap at 7 percent over an underlying at 3.5 percent on a 280,000 wrap note. The spread looks clean until year four, when the buyer refinances out, the underlyi…
Discussion
I have a gap loan sitting in Memphis right now, 14 months in, 11.5 percent, borrower is current and I expect payoff around month 18 when he refinances. That duration I planned. Bu…
Discussion
A parcel I am looking at right now carries a recorded public road along the western boundary, dedicated in a 1991 subdivision plat that was never built out. The county accepted th…
Discussion
I run escrow on conventional deals all day and I have never closed a wrap where the underlying was adjustable, so I genuinely do not know how this works in practice. If the seller…
Discussion
Twelve years of appraising and I still can't settle this for myself. I've got a 3-bed in Maplewood I'm thinking about carrying, asking $279,000, and two interested buyers. One has…
Story
Take a note originated in March 2023 against 18 acres in Ozark County, Missouri. The buyer puts $1,800 down and pays $289 a month for 84 months at 12.9 percent. Somewhere around 3…
Discussion
Take a seller carrying about $180k on a $210k sale where the parcel might actually comp closer to $240k. The question is whether that gap between sale price and appraised value ch…
Discussion
There is a line attorneys use with owners about to carry paper, and it deserves more attention than it gets. The note is only as good as the collateral. The plain version is that…
Discussion
Closed on 18 acres in Adair County, Missouri last October for $14,500 cash. That number I knew. What I did not count on was $340 for the title search I ordered separately because…
Story
Here is a situation worth walking through, because it arrives faster than most people expect. An investor buys a second lien on a small mixed-use in Akron at a discount, paying 31…
Discussion
I bought a duplex in Lakewood, Ohio in 2019 for 187,000 and I'm only looking at seller financing now because a buyer came to me in March and I wasn't planning to sell until at lea…
Discussion
Take 18 acres in eastern tennessee, free and clear, with a small barn built out about four years ago. Bought in 2021 at 142k, and a buyer now wants to carry at 185k with 25k down…
Discussion
Bought a fourplex in akron last year, carried the paper at 8% with a 7 year balloon, and I'm already wondering if I could sell this note to someone in year 2 or 3 if I needed the…
Discussion
Closing on a fourplex in canton ohio next month, seller financing the buyer for 187k at 8% with a 5 year balloon. My attorney mentioned the mortgage gets recorded but I didn't thi…
Happening Now
A buyer coming in on a 3/2 in a stable working class pocket, offered by an owner holding the house free and clear, with 15 percent down and a request for 30 year amortization on a…
Discussion
Read something that said if you originate more than a couple of owner-financed loans you become a mortgage lender and need to be licensed, and that there are rules about balloon p…
Discussion
Say a seller owns a rental free and clear and would rather have a monthly check than a pile of cash to redeploy. A buyer's agent tells the seller to ask for 20 percent down minimu…
Loss
Writing this out because everyone told me owner financing was the easy way to sell and I believed them. Background for anyone new like I was. Seller financing means I sold the hou…
Poll
For anyone building a list of small houses to rehab and expecting to carry paper on several of them, because plenty of likely buyers won't clear a bank right now, the useful quest…
Discussion
Selling a renovated fourplex I own free and clear. Buyer is a contractor, decent operator, thin on liquid cash. Terms we're circling: $425k price, $85k down, $340k note at 7.5%, 3…
Happening Now
Tenant of five years asked to buy the house. Never late, not once, has the rent receipts to prove it. We've talked around 410k, she can put 41k down, and she can't get a bank loan…
Poll
Here is a choice that comes up constantly for a seller carrying paper. A small three bedroom in a working class part of town, owned free and clear, and a buyer who can put 12% dow…
Happening Now
Take an eight unit brick building, all one and two bedrooms, owned free and clear, gross scheduled rent around 96k and NOI last year of 58k after real management and real capex. L…
Discussion
Take a mixed-use building where the seller would sell tomorrow if the buyer could get a loan. The buyer is self-employed two years, and most banks want three, so owner financing c…
Loss
A useful case for anyone carrying paper: a delinquent tax notice reaches the seller two years after closing because the county still has the old mailing address on file. Two years…
Loss
Consider a seller carrying financing on a small 2 bed 1 bath rental, about 780 square feet, sold for 96,000 with 8,000 down and 88,000 financed at 5.5 percent, 30 year amortizatio…
Poll
Say a seller is carrying financing on a small, unencumbered fourplex and has two live buyer conversations. There's a real disagreement about where the underwriting effort belongs.…
Poll
When structuring seller financing, the down payment size is often treated as the main protection, but it's worth separating what the cash at closing actually does from what the no…
Poll
I've got two live offers on a 40 acre parcel I've held about nine years, no debt on it, listed at 265k. Buyer A puts 20% down, 8.25%, amortized on 25 with a 7 year balloon, and hi…
Happening Now
A scenario worth working through for anyone about to carry paper for the first time. Say an owner has a 1.1 acre vacant lot listed at 95k for nine months, two lowballs, and now a…
Discussion
Trying to figure out the actual line items on the seller side. My understanding is I hand over a deed, get a note back, and then money shows up monthly. That can't be free. So: wh…
Poll
I've got two parcels I'll probably sell in the next couple of years, both held free and clear, and I've been reading sample notes to figure out what I'd actually want in one. The…