Happening Now
The gap was not minor. One tenant claimed a right of first refusal on the unit next door if it ever vacated, which appeared nowhere in the abstract. Another had a move-in concessi…
Win
The setup: a 12-unit collecting 7,200 a month on leases signed two and three years ago, against a market that had moved to 750 per unit. The asking price was 1.1 million, underwri…
Story
The case is worth laying out because the gap in the paper is the whole problem. A 14-room house, manager on a rent-credit arrangement, no written protocol for how a vacancy gets r…
Happening Now
Good outcome on paper, but I wanted the asset, not the payoff. My caller had been working that owner for four months and I had a renovation budget sketched out for it, 68k to get…
Story
The seller counted the unit he occupies himself as rented at market rate, $1,150 a month, and he has lived there for nine years. Pull that unit out, restate gross rent at five occ…
Story
A DSCR loan qualifies the property, not the borrower. The lender runs gross rents against the proposed debt service and if the number clears 1.20 or 1.25, depending on the product…
Happening Now
A single spec home carries one construction loan, one interest reserve, one certificate of occupancy, and one sale to clear the debt. A twelve-unit building carries the same singl…
Discussion
I pulled that number from the T12 last week and the broker said the previous owner just had "a rough year." Roof repair, two evictions, one unit sitting vacant for four months aft…
Happening Now
Running a raise right now, half committed, and I keep coming back to this because I did it myself. The 5-unit I passive into in Greensboro was underwritten at 6% management. Owner…
Story
The number that gets first-time owners is not the repair itself but the cascading liability: in most states a heat failure that lasts beyond 24 hours gives tenants the right to wi…
Happening Now
Say a 20-unit building turns six units a year. At $600 a turn that is $3,600 annually, which sounds manageable until you model it against the vacancy gap. If the average unit sits…
Story
Had a 14-unit in Lakeland and a 22-unit in Kissimmee running under the same third-party manager, same agreement, fee was 6% on collected rents at both. I got one consolidated repo…
Discussion
I keep three folders per asset, one for the entity, one for the lender, one for the property itself, and inside the property folder I have a running PDF called "current lease roll…
Story
I had a buyer in Cincinnati, very specific, wanted small multifamily in Price Hill and Westwood, nothing above $180k, 8 percent cap minimum. I spent six weeks working that box. Fo…
Discussion
I have a 7-unit I'm trying to move and one of the tenants converted to month-to-month about four months ago, everybody else has at least eight months left. My first instinct was t…
Discussion
I have been thinking about this because the two methods can produce meaningfully different conclusions on the same property, and the appraiser's selection is rarely explained in t…
Win
Lancaster. Not Columbus, not Dayton, not the suburbs people are already fighting over. I drive through there doing punch list work and the streets look like 2019 Columbus looked b…
Win
I did not catch it until month seven. The agreement calls it an "administrative processing fee" charged to the resident, collected by the manager, retained by the manager. My rent…
Discussion
Take a 10-unit where every door rents at $900. Gross scheduled rent is $108,000. Before a single repair, a realistic expense ratio on a building this size runs 45 to 50 percent, s…
Win
Found the deal through a landlord who'd owned it since 1987 and wanted out before another rent cycle. Rents were running about $180 under market on four of the units, leases month…
Happening Now
A case worth studying: an owner holds 24 units across three small buildings, self-manages, and is spending roughly 18 hours a week on leasing calls, maintenance coordination, and…
Happening Now
Sitting with a 9-unit in Elk Grove right now, asking $1.1M, in-place rents at $9,400 a month. Seller's pro forma gets to a 6.8 cap by taking expenses down to 34 percent of gross,…
Discussion
I run 6 units in the Tulsa metro and have used two different agencies since 2021. Every proposal I get now includes retargeting as a line item, usually $400 to $600 a month on top…
Happening Now
The buy side pencils cleaner on day one because the income is already there, 13,200 a month collected, and my lender will size against that. Build side I'm staring at 18 months of…
Happening Now
Here is a situation worth working through. Take the T12 from a listing broker on a 14 unit in Akron and rebuild it independently. The buyer's number comes out at 94k NOI against a…
Story
Take an 8 unit in the Springfield area of Jacksonville, listed at 1.1 million and collecting 7,200 a month gross, with a seller pro forma showing expenses at 32 percent. Anyone wh…
Discussion
The question is whether a 12 unit project in a mid-size Pacific Northwest market can carry its soft costs at all, or whether the math only starts working somewhere around 30 or 40…
Discussion
Something I ran into on a 9-unit in a secondary market that I haven't resolved. The guide logic is that at five units you're valued on NOI and a cap rate. That's how I underwrote…
Happening Now
A 7-unit building, three 2BRs and four 1BRs, asking 610k with current rents totaling 5,900 a month, is a useful case for understanding commercial multifamily financing for someone…
Discussion
Working a 14-unit at 1.62M asking. My underwriting lands NOI at about 96k after a 5 percent management fee and 300 per unit per year in reserves, so roughly a 5.9 going-in cap. Ba…
Happening Now
A useful exercise in underwriting a small rural multifamily deal: a 10-unit building priced by the seller off a stated NOI and cap rate, with real numbers reconstructed independen…
Happening Now
A 14-unit garden-style property, two buildings, 1968 vintage, in an inner-ring suburb, under LOI at $1.75M with a defensible in-place NOI of $118k, a 6.7 going-in cap, and rents a…
Discussion
Take an 11 unit property bought with rents at 950 across the board, where market now supports 1,150 and 7 of the 11 have already been turned at that number, with four still on leg…
Happening Now
Here is a scenario that stalls a lot of first time multifamily buyers, and it is worth working through with real numbers. Take an 8 unit, 1962 two story, one gas boiler serving al…
Happening Now
A common bind on a value add hold: a 16-unit two-story bought 18 months ago at 1.45 million, financed with an 1.1 million bridge loan, interest only, SOFR plus 350, 24 month term…
Discussion
I'm finishing my salesperson license and looking at a 12-unit at 1.05M as a first commercial-classified purchase, and my operating expense line is guesswork. Specifics I can't pin…
Win
I came into this planning to buy one rental. What I ended up with is a 5-unit in an older brick building, 412k, and the reason I am posting is the tenant files, because that is wh…
Happening Now
My plan was a duplex. Then my agent sent me a 7-unit at 585k and I've been staring at it for a week. The rent roll the listing agent typed up shows 5,320 a month. Three units have…
Win
The insurance binder came back at 17,400 nine days before closing against the 9,600 I had in the model, and for about 48 hours I thought four months of work was gone. Shape of it.…
Happening Now
I have about 240k I want to put into multifamily and two live options in front of me. I'm on the capital side by temperament, meaning I'd rather read documents than fix toilets, b…
Poll
I've read the section on income valuation twice and I think I finally understand why these two buildings are asking the same number. Both are 5 units, same small city, about a mil…
Poll
Take an 11 unit building where in place rent averages 810 and comps support 1,000 to 1,050 on a turned unit. Nine of eleven are month to month, long tenured, and paying on time. T…
Poll
An investor moving from duplexes and a triplex, all self-managed, into an eleven unit building for the first time typically hits a real decision point. Rents on the new building r…
Happening Now
Consider a seller offering two adjoining buildings on separate tax parcels. The 9-unit is a 1974 walkup, six 2-bedrooms at 950 and three 1-bedrooms at 775, totaling 8,025 a month.…
Poll
I've owned land long enough that the holding cost is a tax bill and a mower, so budgeting for a building with roofs and boilers in it is new territory for me. I'm looking at a 12-…
Happening Now
Working up a valuation on an 11-unit I've been asked to list, and the gap between the rent roll and the bank statements is bigger than anything I've seen. Rent roll says 9,100 a m…
Poll
I've been reading the supply side for a while, mostly because I wanted to know when land in these submarkets stops competing with new apartment deliveries. The read most people se…
Win
Take an 18-unit brick walk-up in a first ring suburb, listed around 1.42M, with 21 striped spaces in the rear lot and a lender who wants at least one space per unit for the loan t…
Poll
Building out management services for this size range, five to twenty units, keeps raising the same fee structure question from both sides of the table. The two common shapes are a…
Poll
A scenario worth working through. A buyer has enough down payment for a 6-unit comfortably, or a 14-unit if they bring in one partner and keep almost nothing in reserve beyond the…