Who actually makes the monthly payment on a subject to deal

Question

The operations side of a subject to deal deserves scrutiny before a team touches one. A common description is getting the seller's online login and making the payment from the buyer's account each month. That arrangement carries real risk. If the seller changes the password, or the lender flags an unfamiliar login, the buyer can be locked out of a loan they're responsible for and not find out until the payment is already late. Third party sub2 servicing companies exist specifically to solve this. They typically handle the payment processing directly with the lender, maintain a paper trail separate from a shared login, and monitor the loan for payment changes, insurance lapses, or notices from the lender, for a monthly fee that is usually modest relative to the risk of losing access to a password dependent process. Paying that fee is generally worth it compared to building an operation around a shared password.

Rena Guide · Accepted Answer

Loan servicing means collecting the payment, applying it to principal, interest and escrow, and keeping the record of it. On a subject-to deal the bank's servicer keeps doing that job on the underlying loan. What the third party companies do is sit between you and that servicer: they take your money on a schedule, send the payment to the lender, hold and disburse any seller-carry note payments, and produce a statement both you and the seller can look at.

That third piece is the reason to use one. The seller's name is on that loan for years, and a neutral party generating a monthly record of every payment made is what keeps a nervous seller from calling the bank. Typical pricing I'd expect you to be quoted is a setup fee somewhere around 100 to 300 dollars per loan and a monthly fee in the 20 to 60 dollar range, with extra if they're also administering a seller note or an escrow. Confirm the current fee schedule in writing, since these companies price differently and some won't take a file where the borrower of record isn't their client.

On the password: you're right to want out of that arrangement. The cleaner mechanism is a third-party authorization or limited power of attorney signed by the seller at closing and filed with the servicer, which lets you call in, get payoff and escrow figures, and receive copies of notices. Whether a given servicer honors it, and what form they demand, varies by servicer, so ask them for their form before closing rather than after.

Also get the mailing address on the loan changed to one you control, or you'll never see the escrow analysis.

Rena Expert · Answer

Add the failure modes to what you're budgeting for. Pay from a dedicated account for that property only, never a shared operating account, because a returned payment on a shared account can take two loans down. Kill the seller's autopay at closing in writing, since a seller who forgets it's on will double-pay one month and then stop, and you'll be reconstructing which payment posted.

Watch how the lender applies anything above the scheduled amount. Some servicers hold overpayments in suspense instead of applying them to principal, and if you're sending a round number to keep bookkeeping simple you can end up with money sitting in unapplied funds for a year.

The expensive one is escrow overage refunds. Those checks go to the borrower of record at the address on file, which is the seller. If you didn't change the address, she gets a check for 700 dollars on a house she doesn't own and now she's thinking about the whole arrangement again. Same for the annual mortgage interest statement and any hazard insurance non-renewal notice.

devon_pierce · Answer

On the interest statement, that is the question that trips people up on these. The 1098 gets issued to the person on the note, while the buyer is the one actually paying the interest. It is answerable, but a CPA will want the closing documents in hand before giving that answer, so guessing at it beforehand is wasted effort. Worth pricing an hour of a CPA's time into every one of these.

wendy_park48 · Answer

Read the servicing agreement before assuming the servicer solves the seller communication problem. Several of them say plainly that they're a payment conduit, that they don't verify the underlying loan status, and that they have no duty to notify you if the senior loan goes delinquent for a reason other than your payment. A servicer forwarding your 1,340 a month is not a monitoring service. What belongs alongside it is a standing authorization that lets you pull the loan's status directly from the lender, plus a calendar reminder to actually do it. Check whether the agreement lets them resign on 30 days notice as well, because a couple of them do, and then you're back to the password.

Who actually makes the monthly payment on a subject to deal

4 replies