The documentation package is doing the entire valuation job here, and the assumption carrying the most weight is that lender-accepted appraisal methodology for permanent crops follows operating income, not raw land comps. When you can hand the appraiser a four-year input ledger alongside a Class A water allocation and two seasons of documented yield, you have converted a comparable-sales problem into an income-approach problem. That shift is what closed the $3,800 gap. The blocks at $11,000 were priced on dirt because that was the only defensible basis available to the appraiser.
What you price as certainty on productive acreage: water rights with documented allocation, yield history that is crop-specific and weather-adjusted, and input cost records that show margin at multiple commodity price points. If those three things are in the file and independently verifiable, you can support an income-approach basis and the lender can follow it. Everything else sits in the discount column until you have the receipts, including projected yield improvement, assumed water availability beyond the documented allocation, and any price-per-pound assumption that relies on a single season or a commodity peak.
The risk the thread does not name: pecan yield cycles. Pecan trees alternate-bear, meaning a heavy crop year is typically followed by a lighter one. Two seasons of documented yield at 2,400 pounds per acre is a thin sample for establishing a stabilized income figure, depending on where those two seasons fell in the alternating cycle. If both seasons were on the high side, the income approach overstates stabilized cash flow, and the buyer's basis is built on a number the operation may not reproduce every other year. A lender underwriting on a two-season average needs to know which part of the cycle those seasons represent.
Confirm how your lender treats alternate-bearing cycles in permanent-crop underwriting, specifically whether they normalize yield over a longer sample or take the two-season average at face value.