The site work added $34k to a $150k ADU budget

Question

Priced a 700 sq ft detached at $150,000 hard cost, which I was comfortable with. Then the site work came in.

Existing 4 inch clay lateral, plumber won't tie a second dwelling into it, so it's a new lateral to the main with a street cut. $19,000 with the city's cut permit and repave. Existing 100 amp service can't carry the unit, so 200 amp upgrade and a new subpanel, $11,400. Another $3,600 in grading because the back of the lot falls about three feet and the pad needs fill and a retaining curb.

So $184,000 all in, against $1,900 rent in my submarket. I have a HELOC with $95,000 available and a renovation loan I could still switch to, though that restarts the timeline by roughly two months.

My question is on the financing rather than the dirt. Does it make sense to eat the overage on the HELOC at a variable rate and refinance everything once the unit is leased and seasoned, or take the two month hit and get the whole thing inside one fixed loan? And is $184k against $1,900 still a build I should be doing?

Rena Expert · Accepted Answer

$184,000 at $1,900 is 12.4 percent gross on cost. Strip out taxes on the new improvement, insurance, a maintenance reserve and vacancy and you're somewhere near 8 percent net on cost, in a market where you already own the land. That clears most build-to-rent math. The number that decides whether you should build it is your all-in cost holding steady, and you've already moved 23 percent past your first estimate on site work you had priced at roughly zero.

So before the financing question, ask the plumber and the excavator what else could still surface. The usual candidates on a lot like yours are rock in the trench, an unexpected depth on the main that turns a gravity connection into a pump, and a city sewer capacity fee that is billed separately from the plumber's number and can run four to five figures. Carry 12 to 15 percent contingency on the remaining scope, which on your build is another $20,000 or so of borrowing capacity you need available, not another line in a spreadsheet.

On the debt, the comparison is two months of construction delay against carrying maybe $89,000 of variable rate money for however long it takes to lease, season and refinance. At a HELOC rate in the high single digits, $89,000 is roughly $600 a month of interest, so two months of delay costs you about two months of rent and the extra permit-clock risk, while the HELOC route costs you interest until the refinance closes and exposes you to rate moves in between. If your refinance depends on the appraisal recognizing the ADU's value, and it often only partly does, you may be carrying that HELOC balance longer than you plan.

Confirm the renovation loan's draw schedule and whether it can fund site work already completed, in writing, before you assume switching is available at all. Some products won't reimburse work performed before closing.

aliyah_b · Answer

The $19,000 lateral is the number I'd want a second bid on. Street cut and repave pricing swings hard between contractors because the city's repave spec is where they hide margin, and one of them is always assuming a full lane restoration when the city only requires a trench patch.

joe_delgado5 · Answer

Two months of permit delay is never two months. Everything I've seen described as a two month restart runs three or four because the resubmittal lands behind whatever queue the city has that season. If you go that way, price it at four.

chriswalton8 · Answer

Have you looked at whether a private lender bridges the $34,000 for six months and gets paid off at the refinance? Expensive per month, cheap in total if the term really is short. Depends whether your first position lender allows another lien behind it.

samantha_ruiz · Answer

sable, the HELOC is already the second lien, so a third gets awkward fast and most private money won't sit there for a $34,000 piece. Girder, the question I'd sit with is what the refinance actually returns. If the appraisal only recognizes $80,000 of the build, you refinance into a bigger loan on the whole property and your cash flow narrows. That's the ceiling I keep running into on these.

omar_haddad · Answer

Grading at $3,600 for a three foot fall with a retaining curb is optimistic. Once you're holding fill you're often into an engineered wall, and that's a stamped drawing plus block plus drainage behind it. Ask whether that $3,600 assumes any wall over 30 inches, because that's usually where the permit and the engineer show up.

tonyv88 · Answer

At $1,900 in a market where the main house is presumably renting for more, check that the ADU rent you're using is for a unit with a real parking spot. In the buildings I manage, a detached unit with no dedicated space rents $150 to $250 under one with a space, and your grading plan just ate part of the back yard.

The site work added $34k to a $150k ADU budget

7 replies