23% of boarding house listings in my metro show a license on the MLS sheet and a lapsed renewal on the city portal

Question

I've been cross-checking both for about six weeks now, going through every licensed rooming house that's hit the market here since January. Out of 35 listings that advertised an active license, 8 had renewals that lapsed somewhere between 14 months and 3 years ago. The city portal is public, takes about 90 seconds per address, and almost nobody seems to be doing it. One of the 8 was listed at a 6.4 cap on a 16-room house in a neighborhood where unlicensed conversions have been sitting for two years. The seller's broker cited the license as a material feature of the valuation in the listing description. The license expired in March 2022. I'm curious whether people buying in this asset class are building the re-licensing timeline and cost into their offers, because from what I'm seeing, a lot of buyers are pricing the license as if it's current and ironclad when the city file says something completely different.

leilaqasim · Answer

The one thing I have never seen work is assuming a lapsed license is basically an administrative formality you can cure in 30 days. In the three metros I looked at seriously, re-licensing after a multi-year gap almost always triggers a full inspection cycle, sometimes a zoning re-review, and occasionally a requirement to bring the building to current code on things like egress and fire suppression that were grandfathered under the original permit. I looked hard at a 12-room house in Providence in early 2023 where the license had been lapsed 22 months, and the re-licensing path ran an estimated $40k in remediation before the city would even schedule the inspection, which killed the 6.1 cap the broker was selling entirely. On a small four-unit townhome build I can absorb a timeline surprise, but a boarding house with a dead license is a totally different animal because every week of delay is lost room revenue on a unit count that actually matters. The 6.4 cap on that 16-room house you flagged is probably a 4-something cap once you price in realistic re-licensing, remediation, and six to twelve months of reduced occupancy while the city moves at its own speed.

teresa_iglesias · Answer

Bought a 12-room in Cleveland 2019, license showed active on the MLS, lapsed 19 months prior per the city portal I checked the day after we closed.

23% of boarding house listings in my metro show a license on the MLS sheet and a lapsed renewal on the city portal

2 replies