Midwest mid-size cities keep coming up as the obvious BRRRR hunting ground, and I want to pressure-test whether that reputation is still earning its keep.
Say you are looking at a 3/1 in a secondary Midwest market, purchase at 65k, rehab budget at 35k, ARV target at 145k based on two corridor comps from the past eight months. The 75 percent LTV cash-out refinance would return 108k, meaning you are looking at roughly 8k left in the deal if everything holds. That spread is the whole thesis, and three things can erase it before you close the refi. The appraiser finds no comps inside six months and reaches back to a sale that predates your renovation by over a year. The rental market in that corridor softened enough that your DSCR comes in thin and the lender reprices the note. Or your rehab ran 12 percent over because a mid-size city with one decent GC means you have no real competitive bidding on the work.
The cities that actually support the model right now tend to share a few measurable characteristics rather than a name you can pin on a map. Active resale volume in the specific corridor, not the zip and not the metro, matters because the appraiser works the same data you do. If comparables are sparse, your ARV is a guess that the appraiser gets to correct. Markets where investor activity drove a two-year appreciation run and then stalled leave you with comps that no longer reflect where values settled, which is a refi timing problem built into the acquisition.
The city question is really a corridor-within-city question, and within that, a comp density question. A town with 180k people but most of the BRRRR activity concentrated in four neighborhoods can mean the appraiser has eight solid comps or two thin ones depending on which block you are on.
What is the comp density looking like in the specific corridor you are underwriting, and how far back do you have to reach before the volume thins out?