Where is the line on an investor doing their own labor on a unit turn?

Question

A question that comes up on almost every small multifamily turn. Contractor bids come back higher than the budget wants and a good chunk of the gap is labor. The owner is reasonably handy, has done tile and trim and can hang a door, and wants to know where the line is. The panel is obviously off limits. But one forum will say owner-occupants can pull their own permits and investors cannot, and another will say it is fine as long as you own the building. Those cannot both be general rules, so what is the actual distinction, and how much of it is local? The second part matters more for this method. Does self-performed work affect the refinance at all? If the appraiser cannot tell who did the work, does it matter?

Rena Guide · Accepted Answer

Owner-builder permitting varies by state and often by city within a state, so both things you were told are probably true somewhere. Common shapes: some jurisdictions let any property owner pull permits on a building they own, some restrict owner-builder permits to owner-occupied single family, and some allow it for any owner but require a licensed contractor for specific trades regardless. Electrical and plumbing are the two that get carved out most often. Your local building department will tell you the rule for your address, and if the answer isn't clear you want a licensed professional to read it rather than a forum.

The appraisal question is separate and the answer is that the appraiser mostly can't tell and mostly doesn't care. Value comes from what's there, not who installed it. Your labor doesn't show up as an extra credit, so if you save 12k in labor, that 12k stays in your pocket as reduced spend and doesn't appear as extra value.

What can affect the refinance is permits. If the county has an open permit on the property, or if a lender or appraiser spots work that clearly required a permit and no record exists, that can hold up a closing until it's resolved. Closing out permits after the fact is slow and sometimes means opening a wall you just finished.

One more thing that catches people. If you're funding the rehab with a construction or hard money draw, many of those lenders release draws against licensed contractor invoices and won't reimburse your own labor at all. Ask before you plan the budget around self-performing.

priya_n21 · Answer

This thread is a good advertisement for the passive side. The phrase "open a wall you just finished" is the kind of thing that sends careful money toward a limited partner position.

nicole_adeyemi · Answer

Permits are public record in most places and they follow the parcel forever. It is common to find an unclosed permit from a previous owner that sat in the record for years and only surfaced when someone tried to finance. Before you do anything yourself, pull the permit history on your building. You may already be inheriting something.

mitchell_ray4 · Answer

Do the finish work, sub the rough-in. Tile, trim, doors, paint, all fine and you'll do a better job than the cheap crew because you care. Anything that gets inspected before it's covered up, pay someone whose license is on the line for it.

And honestly cairn, price your own hours. If the unit sits three extra weeks because you're working nights on it, at say 1,200 a month rent you've spent most of the labor savings on vacancy.

Where is the line on an investor doing their own labor on a unit turn?

4 replies