Operator cleared the pref, returned capital, and distributed 30 percent of the upside before anyone noticed the waterfall had a step missing
A deal worth studying from this room: a 70/30 split with a 10 percent pref on a small multifamily hold, 18 months, clean execution on the operations side. The operator cleared the pref, returned capital, then distributed the first promote tier at 30 percent to the money side before the waterfall moved to the next threshold. What nobody caught until the final accounting was that the agreement described two promote tiers but only specified the split at the first one. The second tier defaulted to the same 30/70 by convention, which is what the operator assumed, and the capital provider assumed the split flipped to 50/50 at that point because that is what they remembered discussing. The difference on a $190k gain above the first threshold was about $38k. The operator was not wrong. The capital provider was not wrong. The agreement was incomplete and both parties read the gap in their own favor, which is exactly what people do. The lesson is not that the operator acted badly. It is that a waterfall with two tiers needs the split percentage written next to each tier, not just the first one, and that the moment a promote has more than one hurdle the agreement needs to define what happens to unallocated gain if the deal exits between hurdles. That second point is the one most term sheets skip entirely. When you review your current operating agreements, how many of them actually name the split at every tier rather than just the first one?