Operational problems don't scale linearly and that is what gets people
I lend, I don't operate, but I've watched enough borrowers hit the same wall at the same unit count to have a view on it. The jump from say 12 units to 80 is not more of the same thing. It is a different business.
Up to around 30 units most people are still self-managing or using a PM they can call directly on a Saturday. Maintenance is reactive. Leasing is whoever answers the phone. That works until it doesn't, and it stops working fast once you cross 50 units and have multiple properties in different zip codes. The person who was good at 12 units is now spending 60 hours a week on tasks that should cost $18 an hour and the whole thing is running on their personal bandwidth.
The thing I see most on the lending side is that operators who grew fast never built a maintenance float. At 8 units you can eat a $4,000 HVAC replacement out of cash flow and move on. At 150 units you are replacing 4 units a year on average in the Pacific Northwest climate, which is roughly $20,000 to $24,000 annually just sitting in a category most proformas underwrite at half that. I will not lend against a proforma with $400 per unit per year in capex reserve on a 1980s build. I've seen that number on decks for properties in Lynnwood and Mountlake Terrace and I walk on principle.
The other thing that changes and nobody prices correctly early on is the cost of a bad property manager at scale. At 10 units a mediocre PM costs you maybe 3 or 4 percent occupancy. At 200 units the same performance gap is $80,000 to $120,000 in annual NOI depending on your rent band, and that is before you factor the deferred maintenance they let accumulate. Replacing a PM mid-hold is also not clean, there is a 60 to 90 day transition period where both parties are half engaged and your numbers will show it.
I stay on the capital side partly because I've watched operators who were excellent at 20 units get destroyed at 100, and I've never figured out a reliable way to underwrite the gap between those two versions of the same person.