Does a broker retainer at $1,800 a month beat per-listing pricing at $290 a pop when volume swings this hard
I signed with a per-listing shop last spring. Closed nine deals between March and June, so I paid $2,610 over those four months, fine. Then July through October I closed two, so the same arrangement cost me $580 for the whole back half of the year. That math works until it doesn't, because the shop dropped me down the priority queue when my volume dropped and my August listing sat twelve days longer than it should have while they finished work for the agents paying more that month.
The broker retainer I'm looking at now is $1,800 flat regardless of how many listings I run through it. If I close fewer than seven deals in a quarter, that's worse than what I paid per listing. If I close more than seven, it's better. Last year I did twenty-two total, which is about five and a half per quarter on average, so by the numbers the retainer probably costs me more. But Q2 and Q3 are not the same and that average hides a swing from nine to two in consecutive quarters, which is the whole problem.
The retainer also includes a monthly email to my past buyers and a social drip I am not currently running at all, so there is some added coverage I'm not pricing correctly. I don't know what that's worth to me yet. What I do know is that the per-listing shop treating low-volume months as low-priority months is a real cost that doesn't show up in the invoice.