Does the servicer fee structure eat the workout gain on a low-balance NPN or is that just my deal
Trying to get my head around this with a specific note I'm watching. UPB is $38,400, first position, single family in Memphis. The seller is quoting it at $14,500, so roughly 38 cents. BPO came back at $61,000, which on paper looks fine, but I keep getting stuck on the servicer side when I actually run the numbers forward.
The two workout paths I can see are a loan mod that re-performs over 12 to 18 months, or a deed in lieu that lands me the property and then I figure out disposition from there. The mod path is what I keep trying to make work, but when I add monthly servicing at $65 per month minimum, the boarding fee, any default-related fees the servicer tacks on during the workout negotiation, and then the exit cap rate if I sell the re-performing note, I'm looking at maybe $7,000 to $9,000 net on a $14,500 buy-in over potentially 20 months. That's not nothing but it's also not the spread the acquisition price implies.
The deed in lieu path feels cleaner on paper except I don't know Memphis and I'd be holding an asset I have no boots-ground relationship to manage or sell quickly. Repair unknown, holding costs unknown, and I'd need a local contact I don't have yet.
What I can't tell is whether the servicer fee drag on a note this size is just a fixed cost that compresses every low-balance deal the same way, or whether I'm missing a fee negotiation that changes the math. Did anyone actually push back on a servicer's fee schedule on a note under $50k UPB and get anywhere?