The notes column just says "collateral file incomplete." Incomplete how?

Question

A seller sent me a one-loan tape. First lien, UPB 88k, borrower 26 months down, asking 31k, BPO 104k. The notes column just says "collateral file incomplete, missing intervening assignment."

I don't actually know what a complete file looks like, so I can't tell if that's a small thing or a deal killer. Someone on another forum said you can just record a fresh assignment from whoever sold it to you and the gap doesn't matter. That sounded too easy to me. My first rental hasn't even closed yet so I'm reading this stuff mostly to understand it, but 31k against a 104k value keeps pulling my eye back to it.

What's supposed to be in the file, and which missing pieces actually stop you from doing anything with the loan?

Rena Guide · Accepted Answer

Two documents sit at the center of this. The note is the borrower's promise to pay. The mortgage or deed of trust (which one depends on the state) is the document recorded at the county that ties that promise to the house. Buying a non-performing note means buying both, along with the paper trail proving they traveled from the original lender to you.

A complete collateral file usually holds the original wet-ink note with any allonges attached, a copy of the recorded mortgage or deed of trust, the recorded assignments showing every transfer since origination, the title policy from closing, the full payment history, and any modification or forbearance agreements signed along the way. An allonge is a separate sheet of paper endorsing the note to a new holder when there's no room left on the note itself. An endorsement "in blank" means it names no one, so whoever holds it claims to be the holder.

A missing intervening assignment is the gap where one of those recorded transfers was never recorded. Sometimes it can be cured by getting the prior party to sign a corrective assignment, and sometimes that party is a bank that no longer exists, which turns a paperwork errand into a title action. Whether you have standing to foreclose with a gap in the chain depends on your state's law and its courts, so that question goes to an attorney licensed there before you bid, not after.

Before any of that, order a current title and tax search on the property. A 31k price against a 104k value stops looking cheap if there are 9k of delinquent taxes and a senior lien nobody mentioned.

marcus_hale41 · Answer

I won't look at note images until I've paid for an O\&E search, roughly $75 to $150 depending on the state and the search company. It shows the recorded chain, the tax status and anything junior. If the seller's "missing intervening assignment" turns out to be two gaps and an HOA lien, I've spent a hundred dollars instead of thirty-one thousand.

Worth knowing that sale prices aren't public in about a dozen states, so your comp work behind the BPO gets harder in some places than others.

chriswalton8 · Answer

Who's the seller? A one-loan tape being shopped by email usually means it's been passed down a chain of brokers from a fund that culled it, and the "notes" column is whatever the last person retyped. I'd ask straight out whether they currently own it or are marketing someone else's file.

gregpowell66 · Answer

Honestly the assignment gap worries me less than the house. 26 months of nobody paying usually means 26 months of nobody fixing anything either. If it's vacant in a cold climate you can have a burst supply line and a floor that's gone soft, and your 104k BPO was probably drive-by exterior only.

wendy_park48 · Answer

girder, condition matters, but you can't sell or foreclose a house you can't prove you own, so read the paper first.

Things I'd actually check on this one: is the note endorsed in blank or endorsed specifically to a party that isn't the seller, are the allonges firmly affixed or loose in the folder, does the recorded mortgage date line up with the deed date on the county record, and does the legal description on the mortgage match the deed. If MERS shows up in the chain, get the assignment out of MERS and read who signed it and in what capacity.

Also get a copy of the original note, not just the security instrument. Sellers send the recorded mortgage because it's easy to pull from the county and it proves nothing about who holds the debt.

tonyv88 · Answer

One more thing to verify before you get attached to the numbers: who's living there. I've walked properties where the borrower moved out two years ago and a relative or an actual rent-paying tenant is in place, and now your resolution path involves a lease you never saw and eviction rules that vary by state. Ask the seller for the last property inspection report and the date on it.

The notes column just says "collateral file incomplete." Incomplete how?

6 replies