Someone told me this week that they write the offer before the payoff demand arrives because "the numbers are always close enough.
That framing concerns me more than any specific deal it describes. The payoff demand on a loan in default is not an approximation of the balance. It includes per diem interest calculated to a specific funding date, any escrow advances the servicer made for unpaid insurance or taxes, late charges, attorney fees if the servicer has opened a foreclosure file, and sometimes a reinstatement fee that is distinct from the payoff total. On a loan with a 90-day default and an escrow advance for a lapsed homeowner policy, the gap between "close enough" and the actual wire figure can be eight to twelve thousand dollars on a modest balance. That is not rounding error. That is a reshaped deal. The assumption doing the most work in a pre-foreclosure underwrite is almost always the payoff figure, and writing the offer before that number is confirmed means you are pricing the equity position off a guess. If the payoff comes back higher and you are already under contract, you are either renegotiating with a seller who is running out of auction days and has no patience left, or you are closing into a thinner spread than your model said. Neither is fatal if you built enough cushion, but the question is whether "close enough" was ever a cushion or just a habit. How much spread do you require between your modeled payoff and the confirmed payoff demand before you feel the offer is actually underwritten?