Bought IRT at 16.40 last spring, sitting on about 22 percent plus four quarters of dividends, and I want to put that number next to what I almost did instead.
The alternative was buying a fourplex in Mesquite for 310k. I had the cash, I ran the numbers, the cap rate was around 5.8 at market rents, which is not bad for Dallas right now but nothing special either. What I kept tripping over was the rehab estimate. The place needed about 35k of work before I could even get to market rents, all deferred maintenance the seller had let stack up. So real entry was closer to 345k, and the first year was going to be carry while I worked through the units. I have done that trade a hundred times, I know how it goes, and I did not want to do it again right now.
So I put 48k into IRT instead. Residential REIT, Sun Belt heavy, management team I had read enough on to feel okay about. I was not trying to time anything, I just thought the discount to NAV at that price was wide enough that I had some margin if I was wrong. I was not wrong. Position is now worth about 58.5k and I collected right around 2,100 in dividends over the four quarters.
The fourplex in Mesquite sold two months after I passed. Buyer paid 318k so they got it cheaper than I was offered, and from what I can tell from permits they put more like 50k into it. Good for them. I do not know what their actual return looks like yet.
What I do know is that my 48k is now 60.6k and I did not spend a single hour managing it, which as a GC is maybe the thing I undervalued for years. Time has a cost and I kept pretending it did not because I liked the work.