214k in a Roth SDIRA and the UBIT drag won't pencil
Moved an old employer plan into a Roth self-directed IRA in the spring. 214k sitting in cash at the custodian, earning almost nothing while I argue with myself.
What's in front of me:
- Three private notes through a lender I've done diligence on, first position, 60-65 LTV, 10-11 percent to me, 12-24 month terms. Roughly 60k each, so 180k deployed, 34k held back for custodian fees and a reserve.
- A multifamily syndication, 100k minimum, sponsor projects a 6 percent preferred and a 5-7 year hold. Deal is levered around 65 percent agency debt.
The note stack is clean as far as I can tell. Interest into an IRA is passive, no UBIT, compounds tax free in the Roth. My worry is concentration in one originator and having to redeploy every 18 months, which is real work and real idle cash between payoffs.
The syndication solves the redeployment problem, but the debt financing means part of the income and part of the eventual gain gets treated as debt-financed and taxed inside the account. I asked the sponsor's investor relations person what UBTI showed on last year's K-1s and got "most investors see minimal amounts due to depreciation." That isn't an answer I can underwrite off.
So the decision: all 180k into notes and accept the reinvestment treadmill, or 100k syndication plus 80k in one or two notes and eat whatever the 990-T costs me.
What I can't size is the actual dollar cost of the UBIT on a 100k LP position over a hold. Has anyone here actually pulled the number off a real K-1 rather than guessing?