Loss
Custodian is sitting on their hands because they say the IRA has to be the foreclosing party, not me personally, and finding a trustee's sale attorney who will take direction from…
Discussion
A fund closes on a rolling basis, the manager wants your commitment confirmed in five days, and your custodian needs a direction of investment letter reviewed, countersigned, and…
Happening Now
The workaround most people reach for is a note participation, where the IRA sells a fractional interest in the existing note to a third-party buyer, freeing a portion of the princ…
Story
My custodian took eleven days to wire the purchase price on a $6,200 certificate in Osage County last spring, and by the time the funds cleared I had already missed the county's a…
Discussion
The deal I keep circling is a property in Winston-Salem, seller wants 148k, I'd structure it as a lease option with a tenant buyer already lined up at 162k and a two-year term. Th…
Discussion
Fifty grand went into a bridge fund about fourteen months ago and every K-1 since has read differently from the deal deck I signed off on. Not wildly off, but enough that I cannot…
Story
A private note paying 9 percent inside a Roth looks clean until you price the idle periods. A 40k note that takes six weeks to close, runs ten months, then sits four weeks before…
Discussion
I have 47k sitting in a single note right now, nine months in, balloon due in April. The note pays 9.5 percent so I am not bleeding. But I found a second deal, a 40k private loan…
Discussion
The note matures in February, borrower has been clean every month, so that part is fine. The problem is that finding a note worth funding in this market takes me six to ten weeks…
Discussion
Trying to figure this out because I have $58k sitting in an SDIRA and a sponsor I've worked with before is offering LP interests in a 72-unit value-add in Tucson. The IRA would ow…
Discussion
The first thing to get right is custodian selection, and most people do it backwards. They find the property, then scramble to open the account. A custodian that specializes in re…
Discussion
I'm looking at getting back into another Texas multifamily deal, this time as preferred equity rather than LP. The sponsor is offering 8 percent preferred with a 2x equity multipl…
Story
The conventional wisdom on retirement accounts is that the market does the work: buy index funds, set them and forget them. That logic holds up when a target date fund is the only…
Discussion
I parked 112k into a self-directed Roth about eight months ago, Fidelity rollover from a job I left in 2021. First note I tried to fund was a 65k second lien on a single-family in…
Loss
I put 120k of Roth IRA money into a value-add residential fund in early 2023. The pitch was 14 to 16 percent, the sponsor had a track record I checked properly, and the whole poin…
Discussion
Sponsor is a third party, no relationship to me, a value-add multifamily deal. Minimum check is $100k. I've got about $180k in a self-directed traditional IRA and roughly $120k of…
Discussion
Say a self-directed IRA is funding a single loan to an investor buying a rental, first position, around 60 percent of value. Licensing requirements for making a mortgage loan turn…
Happening Now
Take an investor with 340k across a traditional IRA and an old profit sharing plan, both movable, and a plan built in three lanes: 40 percent first-position private notes, 40 perc…
Poll
Six months in and the thing I still can't settle is whether the tax wrapper is worth what it takes away. Inside the IRA the compounding is clean, especially on interest, and passi…
Discussion
Consider a rollover IRA that's mostly idle, and a sibling who buys and rehabs small houses and could use funding for one. The instinct is to assume family is off limits here. The…
Happening Now
Licensing exam is in three weeks, so this timing is comedy. I've got 142k in a self-directed traditional IRA, mostly cash after a note paid off early. Sponsor I've known for a whi…
Happening Now
A useful case: a self-directed IRA has two notes to one borrower. One matures clean and pays off. The second, say 42k at 11.5 percent with four months left, is secured on a rehab…
Discussion
Custodians commonly quote two paths for a self-directed IRA. A basic account runs a modest annual fee plus per-asset and wire fees, with the custodian signing every document. A ch…
Happening Now
Six months of no deals, but I've finally got a real decision instead of a spreadsheet. Roth self-directed IRA, 168k. A value-add fund I've been tracking is open for another five w…
Discussion
Published fee schedules for self-directed IRA custodians rarely compare cleanly. One common structure is a flat annual fee per asset, say 300 a year with a 50 setup. Another runs…
Poll
I've got both a traditional rollover and a Roth sitting at the same custodian, and I have to pick which one funds the real estate side. The money is the same money. The wrapper is…
Loss
A pattern worth studying rather than dismissing as bad luck. Take an investor who rolls 78k out of an old employer plan into a self-directed account, then spends over a year build…
Discussion
I'm reading the PPM for a value-add multifamily fund. Target leverage 65 percent at the property level, and there's a paragraph telling tax-exempt investors to expect unrelated bu…
Happening Now
Take 214k moved from an old employer plan into a Roth self-directed IRA, sitting mostly in cash while two paths get compared. Option one: three private notes through a single lend…
Discussion
Take an old 401k somewhere in the mid forties that could roll into a self directed account. The goal is income showing up without acquiring a second job, so the lending side appea…
Happening Now
Consider a self-directed IRA holding 178k, deployed as private notes at 11 percent on 12 month terms to unrelated borrowers, with two loans out performing cleanly. A third loan ra…
Win
The boring version of this strategy deserves a walkthrough in beginner terms, because the beginner version is the one most people should be running. Take a 61k balance sitting in…
Poll
The clean version of self-directed IRA deployment is passive and unleveraged: interest from private lending, note payments, rent from a property the IRA owns free and clear, capit…
Discussion
Say an IRA is funding a small private loan and the borrower's attorney drafts the note with the account holder as payee, personally, because that is the name he had. The IRA is th…
Win
Consider 87k of Roth capital deployed into second-lien notes starting in 2022. The book: six notes, all seconds behind institutional firsts on owner-occupied houses in two midwest…
Loss
Wrote a 62k first position loan out of my self-directed IRA to a rehabber I'd worked with twice on the personal side. 11 percent, 9 months, house was a small 3/1 in a working clas…
Poll
Say a sponsor capitalizing a value-add deal offers two ways in for the same $150k inside a self-directed IRA. Preferred equity at 8 percent current with a share of the upside, or…
Discussion
A placement logic worth stress testing. Say an investor holds a couple of small multifamily buildings personally and has an old employer 401k to roll. The reasoning goes like this…
Happening Now
Renovation is what I actually know. Scope creep, change orders, subs who vanish on Fridays. Money is where I'm dumb, so bear with me. Situation: left a job four years ago, 96k sti…
Poll
I've done a few deals with my own cash and I'm now looking at a 140k rollover, and the first decision isn't which deal. It's what fraction of that account has any business being i…
Poll
Consider a small note and lending position run out of a self-directed account for a few years, where a borrower needing a partial release on a Friday runs into a custodian's four…
Loss
Checkbook IRA structure, single member LLC owned by the IRA, me as non-compensated manager. Held two performing seconds and a small unleveraged participation in a rented duplex th…
Poll
Consider an investor setting up a self-directed IRA to move about 60,000 dollars of old retirement money into real estate paper, facing two custodian fee models shaped completely…